Tuesday, January 31, 2012

"Political Retaliation" In Play Against Middletown Library Board President

Middletown's acting Mayor Tony Fiore has asked the President of the Middletown Library Board to resign his position as Board President according to an article posted on Middletown-Patch this morning.

According to Middletown-Patch, a letter was sent to Library Board President Randal Gabrielan last Wednesday requesting his resignation for questionable inappropriate and unethical behavior pertaining to books purchased by the Middletown Library that were penned by Gabrielan.

Randal Gabrielan is the Monmouth County historian and writes books about the history of Monmouth County and its towns. The books are available at many book sellers throughout NJ.

Where the supposed ethical violations come into play in this case is that as Library Board President, Randal Gabrielan signs all the purchase vouchers for the library, including the vouchers that pertain to the books that he has written.

To Fiore and Co., this is a major issue that requires Gabrielan to step down from his position, even though this has been going on for years with the knowledge and approval of the Township and the fact that the library would have purchased the books for its collection anyway.

Randal Gabrielan states in the article that this is "political retribution" for his vocal stance opposing the Township's money grab of nearly $500,000 last year and for the failure of one of the Township Committee's hand picked, newly appointed Library Board of Trustees members not being able to dethrone him as Board President at the Library's January 18th Board meeting, which was the first board meeting after the Middletown Township Committee expanded the membership of the board from 7 members to 9 members to gain greater control over the library's finances.

“This request for resignation is an act of political retaliation prompted by my opposition in 2011 to the Township Committee's demand that the library turn over surplus funds (which did not come from municipal appropriations) to the township and the failure of the mayor's new expanded library board of trustees to elect one of their number, none of whom has any library board experience, to the presidency of the board at the January 18th library board meeting,” According to Gabrielan’s statement posted on Middletown-Patch.

I think that before looking at Mr. Gabrielan, Tony Fiore should be looking closer to home for ethical lapses and request a certain Planning Board member to step down.....


67 comments:

Anonymous said...

They also managed to make the rest of the long-term library board members so uncomfortable with their bullying tactics that one resigned just recently. yes, it is their right to question how things are done and how monies spent but these hand-picked bullies showed absolutely no class in doing so with their thinly veiled insinuations of misappropriating funds. Again, if they were misappropriated, how is it that there was money for the TC to abscond with? It's been hinted at that next they'll try to take control of the library foundation funds to do what they want-and that is not taxpayer money. These guys have absolutely no sense of ethics. FYI, Mr. Gabrielan's books are purchased by many libraries as he is a well-known N.J. historian. This TC will stoop to anything despicable and are an embarassment to Middletown. Why don't they "investigate" TOMSA as has been suggested by many-or perhaps they don't want to cut into their own slush money or future position? I think we need to have a state prosecutor check out all the shady dealings with this TC. They reek. Hope I live to see these creeps get their payback-here on earth in jail or in the world to come!

Anonymous said...

What a disgrace and waste of taxpayer money to buy directly from the author instead of the publisher at a DISCOUNTED rate. Sounds like a backdoor deal to me. How can you stand behind someone that is in clear violation of STATE law. I guess you can say you judge a person by the friends they keep... you can keep this guy, I have enough friends!!!

Anonymous said...

Anon 1:35,

You are so uneducated and have no idea what your talking about. But I guess its better to rant and rave, than to know what your saying. There is no such thing as a "state prosecutor". There is an attorney general, federal prosecutors, and county prosecutors. Take a few minutes and do your homework before you spew your hatred.

Anonymous said...

Anonymous 1:39....No one said the books were purchased directly from the author. More bullshit by the republican bullshit artist republicans in Middletown who visit this blog.. Go spout off to your buddy, Art,who is now out of jail.

The day is eagerly awaited when the law will finally take a look at the tyranny that reigns in this town and maybe the next suit some of them wear will be stripes or orange jumpsuits. That will be a day to celebrate.

Fiore is a loud mouth ,ethically challenged import and he gets bigger for his britches every day.

Anonymous said...

Anonymous 1:43 sounds like Sharfey's pet vicious dog again. Oh well,she can't shoot her mouth off on the APP site anymore without identifying herself.

The arrogance of the whole bunch will finally do them in. Remember Bid Rig and the rest of that scene? No one is above the law....no one !!

Anonymous said...

My God, what a bunch of bullies! They "asked" Mr Gabrielan to step down? I hope he refuses! He's been acting as board president for many years and doing a fine job at it. I love his books, too. If he signs all POs then who was supposed to sign the ones for his books? O'Neal? I think the mayor is being petty about this. This obviously is politically motivated.

Anonymous said...

Anon 1:35. Okay so I don't know all the correct prosecutors but you do-perhaps you've had to help your tc buddies figure out who it is you have to dodge and bamboozle. Speaking about uneducated, you haven't even figured out the proper use of the word "your." Whomever holds the title should look long and hard at this bunch of thugs who are abusing their power by the most unethical means in hopes of securing a lifelong pension for their despicable actions. You're obviously one of them. And I am not spewing hate, I care about the schools, parks and libraries in our town as I live here and raise a family.

Anonymous said...

Yes, and how about the fact that Councilman Schittembrino was texting the new "board members" (cronies) about what to say, a person who openly admitted that she "didn't know a thing about libraries and how they are run", but that she "heard that things should be shaken up" at the library..

And who also had the arrogance and audacity to suggest that another "new" board member (who also admitted to not knowing much about libraries), should supplant Mr. Gabriellan as Board President?

This is a fix, plain and simple and they are out to ruin the library, and become Middletown's Party of "NO"..(like our current, "Do Nothing" Congress) by not allowing the library to conduct their daily business..(and therefore claiming that the library's budget is un-necessary), so they (the thugs of the TC) can STEAL IT!

Typical REPUG move..

Pitbull said...

From the Middletown Patch "Gabrielan has been selling paperback history books he authored to the library at retail cost, submitting vouchers for payment and signing off on and authorizing the payments as board president"

The PO's were made out directly to him. How is that not to the author?

It is common knowledge that libraries get a discount for buying so many books from publishers, so why buy directly from an autor when you KNOW you can get a better deal with the publisher???

PLEASE SOMEONE ANSWER THIS ONE!!!
How is that not WRONG???

I live and pay taxes here to and think that standing up for this behavior is worse than breaking the law in the begining.

If he had abstained from the vote to buy his books from a publisher and then signed the PO for the publisher- no problem. But his arrogance has finally jammed him up...

The Pitbull said...

Now who has the pension padding job again, I am getting confused???

For clarification, see attached-
http://php.app.com/NJpublicemployees11/details.php?recordID=233981

Anonymous said...

Who approves the expenses for the Library? I see Library expenses listed on every Township bill list. It must have been ok for these transactions if the whole Township Committee approved them.

Even newly appointed Library Board member and Township Committee member Murray approved purchases on the December bill list and she wasn't on the Township Committee at the time the purchases were made. How ethical is that?

MiddletownMike said...

I don't know Pitbull, who has a pension padding job? Those that sit on the Library Board of Trustees are volunteers and receive no compensation.

So who are you referring to it couldnt Gabrielan. You must be thinking of some one else.

Anonymous said...

Hey Pitbull,

Mr. Gabrielan is working for Monmouth County - that's why he's listed as a public employee. If you're trying to say that Middletown pays him, you're barking up the wrong tree.

Anonymous said...

As for the bill list, the library board of trustees under the leadership of Gabriellan, made a policy to no longer have PO's signed by the Township. Therefore, the transfers are just a formality because it's the trustees who do approve them.

Anonymous said...

So Mike, answer the million dollar question. Do you condone this breach of ethics? Secondly, if one of the current Township Committee members did this exact thing, would you condone it?

Anonymous said...

"So Mike, answer the million dollar question. Do you condone this breach of ethics? Secondly, if one of the current Township Committee members did this exact thing, would you condone it?"

Double that question...

Anonymous said...

Okay Mayor, someone drops a dime on Gabrielan, you research it and you call him on it. Is it really grounds for immediate request for resignation? C'mon. You and the TC have been letting it slide for years, now you discover it - so just put a stop to it. Let somebody else sign Randy's P.O.'s from now on. Was it really necessary to cause a scandal over this?? Public insinuations, requests for resignation - I think it's overkill. Stop throwing your weight around.

Anonymous said...

What these thugs can't control.they try to destroy !

Rotten,lousy,dirty,gutter politics by Middletown's own low class TC.
No integrity in the whole lot of them. Dishonest?????

What do you think??

Anonymous said...

Doesn't this sound like the same modus operandi used to force out the principal of Middletown South? Take a minor rule infraction, blow it out of proportion, and use your stable of cronies to smear the person's integrity on blogs and the media?

Anonymous said...

As a long-time Middletown resident I am proud of the wonderful library that serves our community. This attempt by our current mayor and his henchmen to destroy the institution which is a jewel in the township by using underhanded tactics is political assassination. Amazing how adding people to the library board who know absolutely nothing about how libraries are run is supposed to make sense. Mr. Gabrielan has served this township and county for many years and his fascinating books have added so much to the literature of Monmouth County. He did nothing wrong by selling books directly to the library. He saved them the time and money that would have been involved in ordering them through a third party. Any discount would have been minimal and shipping costs would have offset it. We need to rethink the governing members of this township before we need to destroy a viable institution with dedicated employees and administration.

Lincroft Dog Girl said...

Anon 7:53 - beautifully put!! I agree with every single word.

Anonymous said...

In a similar fashion, it was the same BS politics that drove Chief Pollinger to resign. He was a decent, fair and well-liked superior and again, he was driven out because he was under the TC's thumb. What I wonder is how these people raise their children to think and how they look them in the eye when teaching them right from wrong? Hypocrites! Remember all the crap Parkinson did with stalking women and having work done at his house by township employees on township time. I might be getting my morally-challenged republicans mixed up with the house work issue but I remember hearing about the cops being called to Philandering Pat's house and us having to pay for his sexual harassment lawsuit. To teach him a lesson, he was made the head of TOMSA and is driving around in a township car on our dollar! I am truly ashamed I ever voted republican with these jerks in control, some of whom live on the very golf course they voted to have built. A la Leona Helmsley, they expect only the little people to pay. Enough already!

Anonymous said...

In a similar fashion, it was the same BS politics that drove Chief Pollinger to resign. He was a decent, fair and well-liked superior and again, he was driven out because he was under the TC's thumb. What I wonder is how these people raise their children to think and how they look them in the eye when teaching them right from wrong? Hypocrites! Remember all the crap Parkinson did with stalking women and having work done at his house by township employees on township time. I might be getting my morally-challenged republicans mixed up with the house work issue but I remember hearing about the cops being called to Philandering Pat's house and us having to pay for his sexual harassment lawsuit. To teach him a lesson, he was made the head of TOMSA and is driving around in a township car on our dollar! I am truly ashamed I ever voted republican with these jerks in control, some of whom live on the very golf course they voted to have built. A la Leona Helmsley, they expect only the little people to pay. Enough already!

Anonymous said...

I think it's important to keep in mind the amount of money we're talking about. Three books were purchased last year, 1 for $20 and 2 at $30 each, and the latter two are hardcovers. Even at retail, there's not much profit there. The mayor is blowing this out of proportion deliberately.

Committeeman Settembrino was on the library board last year. He knew about the sales, so why didn't he make an issue of it then???

Now that one of the board members has resigned, this is all moot anyway. The mayor will have the majority he needs now to do whatever he wants.

MiddletownMike said...

Anon 8:56

Which board member has resigned?

Anonymous said...

Sherry Miloscia resigned rather be part ofthe performance by the TC players!

Anonymous said...

so Pitbull, you're so above board, what do you make of the whole Tim Sodon thing or is that okay ebcasue the Republican party says it is okay? So the $2.00 or so per book that Mr. Gabrielan might have made on the books sales is equal to the huge electrical contract, $75,000 plus, Sodon has and approves, the township cars, etc the TOMSA thugs use for their personal and work use? You have your priorities all screwed up for the sake of your precious party! Oh, yeah, how about Mercantante creating a job for his friend to have health benefits? I suppose that's okay, too? And all the stuff Silva didn't do while he was on the payroll and now to be punished by getting the big payout. Oh, you naughty rethuglicans!

Anonymous said...

So the facts are that the library would have purchased the books anyway and the direct sale saved them the shipping costs.

Aside from the appearance of wrong doing, there doesn't appear to be any.

Anonymous said...

Sure looks like the scum of the earth runs this town today.......

The Pitbull said...

Tim Sodon does not have control over the selection of an electrical contrator that departments of the township uses. So there is no conflict of interest, he just happens to be on the planning board. He is a past chief of the MTFD and dedicated volunteer. He is someone to look up to, not put down... but he didn't break any laws so you probably won't.

The Pitbull said...

Anon 9:52
"saved them the shipping costs.

Not true, they would have ordered other books from a publisher, and it would be cheaper no matter what. This is obvious the culture that Gabrielan has created.

Why buy a hammer at the local hardware store for $10, when you know you can get the same exact hammer for $6 down the street at Lowes...

That is the Million dollar question. Gabrielan directly benefited by not buying from a publisher and knew what he was doing. Anyone that thinks different is discounting the inteligiance of Mr. Gabrielan and his arrogance. And the funniest part is that he is quoted saying that he thought having an attorney at the meetings would be a waste of money, but it would have saved his butt from this whole issue...

Anonymous said...

Tim Sodon is the electrical contractor in town, by resolution. He gets all the work. On the Plannig Board the applicants before the Board has his ear and could direct work needed to his business. After aqll, Buy Middletown.

Anonymous said...

The "culture" Gabrielan created? You mean the culture of remembering Middletown history? The culture of literacy?

And how does one error like this rise to the level of removal?

Example: If a person went around town stuffing mailboxes with accusations that a community group was seeking to alter where traffic could go during construction, and was later proved to be lying, would that person not be fit for any public position based on "the culture of lying" she created?

Just wondering, ......."Pitbull".

Anonymous said...

Dear "The Pitbull,"

You should know that you can't use the word 'arrogance' in the same sentence with "Mr. Gabrielan,"
not that is, unless you know him, since he is an eloquent, highly intelligent, and sweet man. Do you have examples of arrogance pertaining to him? Like we have here with the audio clips of our local elected 'gentlemen?"

Anonymous said...

Thought that "Pitbull" was the person mentioned by anonymous @10:15 a.m on 2/1. Not only did she lie but also tried character assassination against the civic minded caring individuals trying to help in very difficult circumstances during the construction mentioned. Pitbull's only concern was her selfish,distorted viewpoint and getting her own way. Not fit for anything that requires judgement and character.

Integrity and ethics completely escapes this Pitbull.

Anonymous said...

The Republicans confuse "arrogance" with "intelligence" because they are not familiar with the latter, and not very well educated. They must have fallen asleep during their 8th grade civics class, because they have no concept of the "commons". I wonder if Mr. Schittembrino is against those "socialist" educators in elementary schools because they teach the "facts", even though his architectural firm built some of those schools...

This is the mentality that we are dealing with..

Question, who is going over the Township Council's accounting with a fine toothed comb?

I bet you would find more malfeasance and corruption if you looked there, rather in the library!

Anonymous said...

The Republicans confuse "arrogance" with "intelligence" because they are not familiar with the latter, and not very well educated themselves. They must have fallen asleep during their 8th grade civics class, because they have no concept of the "commons". I wonder if Mr. Schittembrino is against those "socialist" educators in elementary schools because they teach the "facts", even though his architectural firm built some of those schools...

This is the mentality that we are dealing with..

The real question should be.. who is going over the Township Council's books with a fine toothed comb?

I bet you would find more malfeasance and corruption if you looked there, rather in the library!

And Mr. Pitbull, you seem like one of those individuals that gets confused and angry when confronted by a person of intelligence because you seem to not be acquainted with the tools of acquiring that intelligence...schools and libraries!

Good day, sir.

Anonymous said...

Anon 5:58 PM, Jan. 31,

The Library Board led by Santa Claus could have made a policy change and that would not have relieved Tony Merchantante, Township Administrator, and the Township Committee from the legal obligation to thoroughly review and approve payment for all library expenses. Tony Fiore, as Mayor, and Merchantante, as Administrator, are just as accountable for what happened as the Library Board and its President. There is no dodging of accountability by the township committee and township administrator by claiming their approval of the library expenses that they sign-off on is just a "formality".

When this issue surfaced, a responsible Mayor and Township Administrator would have met with library representation to discuss an appropriate remedy and strongly recommened policy changes to correct and avoid this kind of situation in the future. Instead Fiore and crew chose to make it a political issue because it involved library laundry.

When there was recent questionable activity that may have led to G. Silva's retirement, the township committee chose not to air their laundry in daylight and instead burned it in the dark under the flag of 'personnel issue'. Someone should try to dig through those ashes to see what remains.

For years the local Republican Party majority has mismanaged the township and when there was little left to pillage there, as a result of a 2% tax levy cap, the township committee turned their greedy eyes towards the library and in one short year have injected mismanagement into the oversight of its daily operations and future well being. What is next on the pillage list?

The Pitbull said...

Schools and libraries shape the future of this wonderful community. I am very fluent with the resources to obtain knowledge and information. Gabrielan is an arrogant man who knows how to make the puppets dance in his favor. All you have to do is talk to him for five minutes and you will see.

Still no answer to the million dollar question - Why buy the books from the author when you KNOW you better a better deal with the publisher???

Anonymous said...

It's not a "million dollar question" just because you say it is "Pitbull".

It was an oversight, hardly high crimes and misdemeanors.

And if arrogance was cause for removal, why are we not staring at a row of empty chairs at TC meetings?

Here's a million dollar question for you...

How many of your fellow Middletowners and neighbors are you willing to slander, harass and drive from their positions for the sake of political ambition?

And another...

Is "potential" libel and slander as serious as "potential corruption"?

MiddletownMike said...

Pitbull,

Why don't you tell me what the cost of the books would have been if purchased through a distributor as opposed to buying directly from Randall Gabrielan?

I think once you factor in shipping and handling the cost of the books sold directly from the source as opposed to the distributor would be nearly the same.


And after all, don't we want to encourge our residents as well as our government agencys to "buy Middletown" first?

Anonymous said...

Anon 1:32 brings to light an interesting point. Septembrino is an architect who apparently designs schools, maybe other public buildings. I wonder how much his political influence or insider knowledge has helped him in this. I think he may work for Eatontown Borough as the "Borough Architect" if it is him it is another public payroll he is on. Any conflict of interest here?

Anonymous said...

The "cheerleader" is this character that writes under multiple monikers such as Legion and now Pitbull. Can't run her mouth on the APP anymore because one must use a Facebook link to post and a real name is required.

Anonymous said...

Where is the logic in paying an extra $6000 to an attorney to attend meetings? The library still would have purchased the history books for about the same price. There has been no misuse of public money here.

Anonymous said...

Anon 8:17:

Does it really matter if there is in fact a conflict of interest? By Fiore's ultra strict standard of conduct, even "potential' corruption or confict is reason for removal.

When can we expect Fiore to ask for Settimbrinos's resignation?

Anonymous said...

A better question to ask is how many other books at the library are bought DIRECTLY from the authors???

Just for comaprisson...

Anonymous said...

Mike,

"I think once you factor in shipping and handling the cost of the books sold directly from the source as opposed to the distributor would be nearly the same."

Don't you think that is a question for the library director, not a commentor on a blog? If you do find out, please share it with us all. Very interested to find that out.

MiddletownMike said...

Anon 2:01

Here is a link to Amazon for books written by Randall Gabrielan:

http://www.amazon.com/s/ref=a9_sc_1?rh=i%3Astripbooks%2Ck%3Arandall+gabrielan&keywords=randall+gabrielan&ie=UTF8&qid=1328174937#/ref=sr_pg_2?rh=n%3A283155%2Ck%3Arandall+gabrielan&page=2&d=1&keywords=randall+gabrielan&ie=UTF8&qid=1328174957

And here is a link to the books listed at Barnes and Noble:

http://www.barnesandnoble.com/s/randall-gabrielan?keyword=randall+gabrielan&store=allproducts

The prices for his books online do not appear to be significantly cheaper than what he sold books directly to the library for.

Without knowing what books were sold to the library a direct comparison can't be made but I think we are in the ballpark.

Barnes and Noble would not have been cheaper while Amazon in a few instances could have been anywhere from $2-$5 less expensive depending on title.

So if you ask me, there is no significant difference between the library purchasing the books through a distributor or directly from Mr. Gabrielan.

Anonymous said...

Mike,

Libraries get an upwards of 40% discount off RETAIL because they buy in such large quantities. So if you are comparing those prices, then that is NOT correct.

That is what I refering to from the begining. Why buy the book directly from the author for retail when you get such a discount from the publisher???

I just don't understand the logic here? Someone knew what they were doing and DECIDED to go this route!

MiddletownMike said...

Anon 8:33,

First off these books weren't purchased in bulk, they were purchased piece meal over several years. So to say that upwards of a 40% could have been received it purchased through a distributor may not be accurate.

I have requested rather obscure new books from the library that need to be ordered in the past, I know that they didn't come from a distributor because I witnessed the library aid look the book up on Amazon and then place a purchase ticket for approval with the library.

Did the library wait for weeks until they placed the order to ensure that they could buy in bulk? No, I was called within a week to tell me the book could be picked up.

The point of the matter is neither one of us, I assume, have seen any of the original purchase orders for the books purchased that was signed by Gabrielan. We don't know if they were stand alone purchase orders or contained a dozen other titles that would entitle the library to a significant discount if purchased through a distributor.

There are reasons for everything that we are not always privy to.

Was Gabrielan wrong for signing off on the purchase orders? Yes, but the books would have been ordered anyway and more than likely the same way.

Is this lapse of judgment a criminal offense that would require Gabrielan to resign his position? No, I don't think so.

The library had been buying books directly from him for several years and NO one had an issue with it until the Tony Fiore and the Middletown Republicans couldn't gain control over the library even after expanding the Library Board and packing it with their supporters.

Anonymous said...

http://kohaopac.mtpl.org/cgi-bin/koha/opac-search.pl?idx=au&q=Randall+Gabrielan

Anonymous said...

And to your point Mike, the only reason you are pro-Randy is because he is an opponent of the Middletown Republicans. You are no better than the people you chastise.

How many other authors sell directly to the Middletown Public Library besides Randall Gabriellan? Probably none. Face the fact that he used his position to force the library to buy his books and then signed off on it. Is it criminal? Probably not. How many people do you think are clammering at the MTPL to read "Postcards from Brooklyn" or whatever else he wrote. Do we care about reading about Tinton Falls or Fair Haven? Probably not but he forced the library to buy the books. That's the problem here. Go on and make your political grandstand along with your buddy from Swimming River Road. The facts are the facts and you know it.

Anonymous said...

Anon 1:39, 1/31,

The only friends you have are your political cronies is this town and they don't have any more idea of ethics and integrity than you do....none,zilch !!

Anonymous said...

Pitbull on 2/1 at 7:16...

The only thing you are fluent in is s
slanderous vicious tongue. That you are more than fluent with....and use it all the time again anyone you chose, about lots of things you really know absolutely nothing of fact.

Peddle your venom on MMM,your pal,Art's blog now that he's out on bail.

MiddletownMike said...

Anon 12:19,


What's your point?

MiddletownMike said...

Anon 1:31

He didn't force the library to buy anything, the books would have been purchased regardless.

Lincroft Dog Girl said...

I can't believe what a big deal is being made out of this. He signed his own POs. Boo hoo. Big friggin' deal.
1:31 - you wanna know who cares about reading his books about Fair Haven and Tinton Falls? Me! Moi. That's right, I live in and grew up in Middletown but I have an interest in the history of our area. Randy's books have brought me much knowledge and entertainment. I was thrilled with his first Images of America book and I've been thrilled with every one since then. I've met the man. He's a nice guy and a reliable historian. All of you people trying to tar and feather him because of some warped political agenda should be ashamed of yourselves! "Face the fact that he used his position to force the library to buy his books and then signed off on it." Are you for real?? FORCED the library to buy his books?? Oh yeah, he really strong-armed them, didn't he. He has authored a popular series of historical books about Middletown and surrounding towns. Did you ever think that MTPL patrons may want to read them? May have actually requested them? Yeah right, the library was forced into buying them. I've read a lot of BS on this blog and I'm sure I'll read a lot more. Most of the time I just shake my head and try to ignore the stupidity. It's all a bunch of political crap. But Randy Gabrielan being asked to resign because of something like signed POs? And some of you agreeing with that request? That's ridiculous.

Anonymous said...

Anonymous 1:31pm said,

"Do we really care about reading about Tinton Falls, or Fair Haven"...probably not"? Well, whoever you are, I can tell you that the Middletown schoolchildren who have assignments on Middletown history, or Monmouth County history every year care about these books and reading about their town and county because they need them to do their homework assignments (and they get them at the Public Library because their school libraries, don't have them..as a matter of fact, the Middletown Schools don't even HAVE libraries in them), I wonder whose bright idea that was?

The ignorance displayed by the TC and their supporters seems to know no bounds...

The first poster got it right. What a disgrace this Mayor and Town Council are for perpetrating this witch hunt against the library...and Mr. Gabrielan.

Susan O'neal said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...

On Tony Fiore's character assassination attempt on Randy Gabrielan: (especially the little mayor's quote "I smell corruption:)
Smoke and mirrors is a metaphor for a deceptive, fraudulent or insubstantial explanation or description. The source of the name is based on magicians' illusions, where magicians make objects appear or disappear by extending or retracting mirrors amid a confusing burst of smoke. The expression may have a connotation of virtuosity or cleverness in carrying out such a deception.

Deflect
verb
1. distract, divert, sidetrack, draw away, turn aside a maneuver to deflect our attention from what was happening

Anonymous said...

If the Mayor wants to hold everyone to a strict standard, perhaps he should hold himself to the same.

Found this online on the Patch...

Looks like the mayor "borrowed" a title and blog idea from Art Gallagher, used the same title himself, rehashed the information, and passed it off as an original concept.

He seems to think that as long his buddy Art is OK with it, he does not have to use proper citations.

Judging from his comments, the mayor THINKS he properly credited Gallagher, but if you read his Patch blog, he only gives a shout out to Art's blog, says Art mentioned the topic too, but does not properly cite that the title and entire concept are a rehash of something Art wrote in his blog.

For SHAME! This reeks of "potential plagarism"! Resign at once!!


http://middletown-nj.patch.com/blog_posts/politics-doesnt-need-to-be-a-blood-sport

Anonymous said...

http://www.moremonmouthmusings.net/2011/06/24/politics-doesnt-have-to-be-a-blood-sport/

Hey Anon 6:36 you're right!
Art had a column on 6/24/11 called Politics doesn't have to be a blood sport, and then the very next day, the mayor had a column in the Middletown Patch called,
Politics doesn't need to be a blood sport!

Apart from the copying, nice to see where Fiore gets his ideas from!

MiddletownMike said...

Susan,

Thank you for educating us on the process of how certain books for the library are purchased, particularly those books that have been authored by Mr. Gabrielan.

For clarification, I was not personally suggesting that books should be purchased through online retails such as Amazon or Barnes and Noble. I just wanted to show some of the critics that if books were bought online that the savings would not be as great as they claim.

I hope now that your comment puts this criticism to rest.

I am also going to post your comment to the main page of this blog for others to see, read and respond to.

Anonymous said...

Anon 6:31
I remember reading that Ray O'Grady told the undercover FBI agents he "could smell a cop a mile away." Did not work out to good for Ray, maybe this mayor should get his nose checked.
The only thing that stinks here is political strong arming by this lackey mayor and committee.

Anonymous said...

"Do we care about reading about Tinton Falls or Fair Haven? " Here's an FYI for you library haters who know absolutely nothing about the value of libraries. Our library has many visitors from ALL OVER THE COUNTRY who come to our library to do geneology, research historic homes (real estate agents, too) and use the N.J. History Room for their studies, which include Mr. Gabrielan's books.Additionally, we have The Red Bank Register online which is used extensively by people all over the world to do geneological research. So to answer your question, yes, genius, there are people who are actually interested in these books to discover their origins. Just in case you didn't know it, our area is famous for it's significance to the American Revoluntion, The Battle of Monmouth, it's large European immigrant population, Lenape Indians, the landing of Henry Hudson, etc. Thankfully, we have excellent teachers who know how to use these resources for our students' benefit rather than rely on the TC idiots who discount local history books and the library in general. Use the TOMSA slush funds for your crooked purposes and leave our library alone! Go back to wherever you came from and say hello to Snooki!

Anonymous said...

Susan,

I the last two years, how many other authors were books DIRECTLY bought from???

And who were they?

Anonymous said...

Anonymous 2/2 @10:30 p.m.,

What difference does it make ? Stop this political witch hunt and character assault against Randall Gabrielan.

Don't you ever learn ??