By Randall Gabrielan
The proposed budget of the library is filled with excessive charges by the township that are the root of the library’s current fiscal problems, the consequence of efforts by the township committee to take library funds for their use. I focus on one issue where I have expertise, casualty insurance. The township is charging the library a greatly excessive share of its overall largely self-insured costs using a percentage that is much in excess of the library’s share of the risk. Take workers compensation, an insurance that is easily rated for its standard costs which are essentially relative to the type of employment covered. Office and library workers are rated lower because they generally incur fewer and less severe claims. Police and public works employees take higher rates to recognize their typical and greater incidence of claims. Calculating a standard cost to start the process would produce a much lower figure for the library. Later modifications from overall experience is a legitimate practice.
Liability insurance, probably not by coincidence, was charged the same percentage for a coverage where the library would likely have an even lower share of the total risk. Libraries, which have few accidents and claims, take low rates while a municipalitiy’s liability charges are greater for streets and police operations. Take automobiles for example and compare the library’s two vans with the great number of vehicles elsewhere in the township. The charge to the library is a typical example of the township seeking to take money for itself that belongs to library operations.
Branch closings would produce smaller savings than the township would imagine because higher paid branch employees would after returning to the main library could result in the termination of the lowest ranking employees in their class. However, much of what the township claims about library funding, when not false, is specious. Take the equalized valuations that are the start of library funding. While it is true that when values decline, statutory library funding declines. However, the township can adjust its tax rate, but the library can do nothing about valuations. Thus, the township is taking from the library funds governed by law to subsidize its own budget. The township committee lies by claiming the board previously “overspent,” this their excuse for not having started earlier its raid on library funds. The statutory, property values based appropriation is a minimum for libraries while municipalities that choose to provide adequate support have in the past appropriated more, a practice admittedly in decline in today’s fiscal environment. In addition, had the library retained its surplus, built largely from non-public funds, it would have been able to weather the present fiscal crises. In short, whereas the former board built a great library, with fine support from former township committees, support that was readily and publicly acknowledged, the present township committee seeks to dismantle that library system.
Correspondents to this site, typically anonymous cowards, will attempt to discredit my words in view of my departure from the board over a perceived trifling offense, one buried ambiguously in statute, one that requires a 17 page decision to understand fully, an offense comparable to driving a mile over the speed limit, a book sale practice with minor proceeds that was on-going for over 10 years without objection by the township’s purchasing department. Oddly, they seek to charge for purchasing activities that could be more effectively handled by the library. Well, effectiveness in township operations was never the issue.
Randell Gabrielan is the former president of the Middletown Library Board of Trustees
Showing posts with label Randall Gabrielan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Randall Gabrielan. Show all posts
Wednesday, January 16, 2013
Wednesday, November 14, 2012
Middletown Library In Dire Financial Straights, Its Future Is In Jeopardy
A number of people over the past year, have been expressed their concerns about the future of Middletown's library, chief among them have been Randell Gabrielan and Linda Baum, who have warned repeatedly of the consequences that are now shaping up to take place, due to the Township's meddling in the affairs of the library and the raiding of it's funds. Library hours and services will soon be cut back, branches will be closed and possible employee lay offs could be starting next month or very early in the new year.Consider how important our library has been to our community and all the good it has done for Middletown, particularly in the aftermath of Hurricane Sandy, it's a damn shame what's been happening to it and the fate that awaits it, starting tonight, at the monthly Board of Trustees meeting. Tonight, the Board of Trustees will be discussing the budget for next year and thus the fate of its ongoing operations.
According to the latest blog post by Library Director, Susan O'Neal (posted on the library's website yesterday) - Library Working on 2013 Budget - the situation seems dire:
...Some very hard decisions lie ahead, and the Board of Trustees will be discussing this budget, starting tomorrow night. The details are not available yet, but we're prepping for a budget with these facts at hand.
1. The budget from the Township, called the municipal appropriation, will be reduced by 3.84% to $3,470,977, or $139,407 less than the 2012 appropriation. The cumulative decrease is 20% in 4 years.
2.Of this, $1,333,493 is expected to be chargebacks to be paid back to the Township for payroll, health care and retirement contributions and insurance costs. That's 40% of the municipal appropriation for the library, and we haven't even written out what we need to spend for books. These chargebacks are $300,000 more than was requested in 2011.
3. The net change in the financial picture since July of this year is -MINUS $477,407. Some of you predicted this last year when the library transfered nearly $500,000 in reserve funds to the Township.
What is there that can be done by library supporters/patrons to try and head off potential service cuts or branch closures? Ms. O'Neal states in her blog post:
"...The budget discussion will take place in open session, of course, and, hearing your priorities will be helpful to us as it is decided what stays and what goes....
You can come to the meeting or send me your comments. All signed comments will be shared with the Trustees of the Library."
If you can't make it to tonight's meeting, you can send your comments to the Library Director via her email - soneal@mtpl.org
The Middletown Library system has often been described as the "Jewel" of our community, I hope that residents make themselves heard loud and clear, in order to head off or lessen the severity of potential budget and/or service cuts that seem imminent. The jewel has lost a lot of it's shine over the past 20 months, to allow it to be tarnish and grow dim any further would be wrong.
Tuesday, October 23, 2012
Destruction of Library Board is Reason to Vote Democratic in Middletown
This letter appears online today at the Atlantic Highlands Herald
I urge the election of Linda Baum to the Middletown township committee because she is intelligent and possesses sharp, sound financial acumen, while the opposition Republican campaign is morally bankrupt. Mr. Massell has claimed to be eager to find waste in Middletown government spending. Since his party has had unbroken control for a generation, one would believe that the present administration is responsible for remaining waste. He claims to have saved Middletown money by single-stream recycling. However, Middletown was late to adopt this practice which became available through enormous equipment investments by recycling companies, not by municipal action. Massell claims that the township’s sale of the swim club was a win for the taxpayers, but he is part of the same organization that acclaimed the benefit given to Middletown by its purchase some years ago. Obviously, he implies they made a mistake by buying the swim club in the first place.
The worst of the misdeeds of the present administration is the destruction of an independent Middletown Library board of trustees and their replacement by political tools. The new board members are largely drawn from the Middletown Republican County Committee and follow the dictates of the township committee. After the township committee raided the library last year for about $500,000 of its surplus, funds raised almost entirely from non-municipal sources, the new board has continued the depletion of the library’s reserves, monies accumulated for needed repairs and capital improvements, expenses that had been previously paid by township appropriation. In addition, the new library board has acquiesced to inappropriate township charge backs for which they receive either no justification or an inadequate accounting. In an area where I have expertise, property and casualty insurance, the township’s excessive charge back is tantamount to theft by the municipality of funds from an organization where state-mandated funding is designed to remove the library from political manipulation. The township committee has put in place actions that will destroy the standard of library service that Middletown residents have enjoyed for many years.
Ms. Baum’s long experience in finance and her intelligence make her clearly qualified to serve the township. Her willingness to speak out over irregularities in the present administration’s conduct of its affairs demonstrates that her voice will be heard over the self-serving dealings of a one-party machine.
Randall Gabrielan
Middletown, NJ
I urge the election of Linda Baum to the Middletown township committee because she is intelligent and possesses sharp, sound financial acumen, while the opposition Republican campaign is morally bankrupt. Mr. Massell has claimed to be eager to find waste in Middletown government spending. Since his party has had unbroken control for a generation, one would believe that the present administration is responsible for remaining waste. He claims to have saved Middletown money by single-stream recycling. However, Middletown was late to adopt this practice which became available through enormous equipment investments by recycling companies, not by municipal action. Massell claims that the township’s sale of the swim club was a win for the taxpayers, but he is part of the same organization that acclaimed the benefit given to Middletown by its purchase some years ago. Obviously, he implies they made a mistake by buying the swim club in the first place.
The worst of the misdeeds of the present administration is the destruction of an independent Middletown Library board of trustees and their replacement by political tools. The new board members are largely drawn from the Middletown Republican County Committee and follow the dictates of the township committee. After the township committee raided the library last year for about $500,000 of its surplus, funds raised almost entirely from non-municipal sources, the new board has continued the depletion of the library’s reserves, monies accumulated for needed repairs and capital improvements, expenses that had been previously paid by township appropriation. In addition, the new library board has acquiesced to inappropriate township charge backs for which they receive either no justification or an inadequate accounting. In an area where I have expertise, property and casualty insurance, the township’s excessive charge back is tantamount to theft by the municipality of funds from an organization where state-mandated funding is designed to remove the library from political manipulation. The township committee has put in place actions that will destroy the standard of library service that Middletown residents have enjoyed for many years.
Ms. Baum’s long experience in finance and her intelligence make her clearly qualified to serve the township. Her willingness to speak out over irregularities in the present administration’s conduct of its affairs demonstrates that her voice will be heard over the self-serving dealings of a one-party machine.
Randall Gabrielan
Middletown, NJ
Monday, July 23, 2012
Video: Middletown Library Board of Trustees Meeting 7/18/12
Last week's posting "Library Board Approves $338K Transfer Of Funds To Township At Last Night's Board Meeting; Former Board President Gabrielan Speaks Out" has garnered 27 comments thus far. I'm sure that if people take the time to watch this video of the 7/18/12 Middletown Library Board of Trustees meeting more comments will be forthcoming.
Two minutes into the video the Board opened the floor to public comments, it was then that former Board President, Randall Gabriellan, addressed the Board and wondered why they were not doing their due diligence in supporting the Library in which they oversee.
Linda Baum followed Mr. Gabrielan, she pointed out that the increases and chargebacks that the Township of Middletown was requesting the Library reimburse the township for were inaccurate and they should be questioned and reviewed by the Library Board before taking them at face value.
The Board later approved the transfer of funds requested by Township without questioning how the new figures were derived.
Here is the meeting agenda for the 7/18/12 meeting and the minutes from the June meeting of the Library Board of Trustees.
Two minutes into the video the Board opened the floor to public comments, it was then that former Board President, Randall Gabriellan, addressed the Board and wondered why they were not doing their due diligence in supporting the Library in which they oversee.
Linda Baum followed Mr. Gabrielan, she pointed out that the increases and chargebacks that the Township of Middletown was requesting the Library reimburse the township for were inaccurate and they should be questioned and reviewed by the Library Board before taking them at face value.
The Board later approved the transfer of funds requested by Township without questioning how the new figures were derived.
Here is the meeting agenda for the 7/18/12 meeting and the minutes from the June meeting of the Library Board of Trustees.
Thursday, July 19, 2012
Library Board Approves $338K Transfer Of Funds To Township At Last Night's Board Meeting; Former Board President Gabrielan Speaks Out
Former Middletown Library Board of Trustees President Randal Gabrielan, sent me his comments last night shortly after the current library board voted in favor of turning over $338,493 to Middletown Township, which the township last month stated was owed by the library to cover its portion of pension, hospitalization, and workers compensation expenses for budget year 2012.
I first posted that something fishy was going on at the library when I was informed that both the Mayor, Tony Fiore and his hench-woman on the library board, Committeewoman Stephanie Murray, were seen leaving the office of Library Director Susan O'Neal several times early last month and Linda Baum followed it up by submitting a blog post after last months library meeting which detailed the sneaky, underhandedness and questionable accounting that lead to this latest money grab that now places the Middletown Library's finances in a precarious position.
Here is what Mr. Gabrielan had to say last night before the current library board approved the transfer of funds:
I first posted that something fishy was going on at the library when I was informed that both the Mayor, Tony Fiore and his hench-woman on the library board, Committeewoman Stephanie Murray, were seen leaving the office of Library Director Susan O'Neal several times early last month and Linda Baum followed it up by submitting a blog post after last months library meeting which detailed the sneaky, underhandedness and questionable accounting that lead to this latest money grab that now places the Middletown Library's finances in a precarious position.
Here is what Mr. Gabrielan had to say last night before the current library board approved the transfer of funds:
After seeing the proposed new budget, I was shocked, but not surprised. After the township committee raided library surplus for about $500,000 last year, the smart money asked “how will they get the rest?” The hopeful thought perhaps the township committee had a modicum of decency, but this proposal shows there is no hope and no decency. After I declared that the committee’s taking of funds through the bullying of the trustees was tantamount to the committee’s declaring war on the library, the only question should have been when and how would the next attack come.
The township charges to the library range from the unjustified, to the exaggerated to the ridiculous, the latter the characterization of the casualty insurance charges, a subject of my expertise. The 14% figure was either pulled out of the air or based on an irrelevant statistic that has no relationship to the library’s risk to the township’s overall risk of loss. It is not merely a puffed-up figure to permit a small reduction, since the measure of risk for the library, depending on how workers compensation is treated, is closer to 1.4%. Figures do not lie, but liars figure, so justification was either a small or likely no part of the equation. The proposed budget is nothing less than an evil money grab, an example of the township using the state- mandated separately financed library as a profit center. They chose a deceptive way to accomplish this raid. They will seek the surplus now, then take these unjustified charges from future appropriations, thereby cutting into library operational funds and ending library service as we have known and enjoyed for decades.
The committee’s expanding and packing the library board was simply an effort to gain control, a battle in their war was to end the practice of an independent library board of library advocates. This township committee does not tolerate dissent. But how will you, the board, defend or even rationalize these numbers?
Everything comes to an end including all terms of public service. As my position ended and I looked back on my service, I took pride in being a major force that built this library. How will you look back on your service? As being political tools who turned over governance of the library to the township committee? Political tool is a gentle term compared with what others might say, but I do not have a grip with the library board. Indeed, I sympathize with your position. But what will you do?
Quoting a remark attributed to Edmund Burke, “The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men – and good women – to do nothing. I urge you to defeat this proposal and tell the mayor that the future of the library and the independence of its board are not up for grabs and do not exist for his budgetary convenience. If not, you may wish to consider resigning. Think of how you will look back on your service.
With respect to good people doing nothing, I find it incomprehensible how anyone who supports the library can tolerate a township committee in continuous control for a generation that does not have at least one member who will serve as a voice of dissent and as eyes on the fiscal irregularities that have been visited upon the people of Middletown.
Regarding that unbroken reign of the existing forces, I’ll repeat Lord Acton’s dictum that power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely. The budget proposal is evil and corrupt. I urge you to turn it down.
Tuesday, May 1, 2012
Gabrielan: Library Board About The Public, Not Politics
This letter to the editor appears online today at the Independent, it was written by former Middletown Library Board of Trustee President Randal Gabrielain. The letter contains a few harsh words critical of the Township Committee and the circumstances that lead to his resignation from the library board earlier this year.
I left the Middletown Public Library board of trustees after 25 years’ service following a campaign of vilification by the mayor. Some wonder why, especially in view of the denial of wrongdoing.

One hopes the new board realizes that library trusteeship is about the public, not themselves, requires advocacy for the library, not the governing body, and is about service, not politics. I wish them well, not merely for their sake, but for the well-being of the library so beloved by the people of Middletown.
I expressed my thoughts in these remarks at an honors ceremony at the April 18 meeting of the board of trustees:
Since many have commented on why I am not on the board, often in craven anonymity, I add my word on the accusations about conduct: They are preposterous. With respect to the cited statute, it is ambiguous. With reference to its interpretation, it is ridiculous.
Anyone who really knows anything realizes I am no longer on the board as a consequence of political retaliation for opposing the township’s takeover of library funds.
Why did I leave? When an all-powerful governing body, one in office for a generation or more, which operates as if might makes right, is out to get you and will stoop to tactics as low as spreading innuendo with one’s employer, let alone what other dirty stunts they could employ, discretion may be the better part of valor. The Township Committee was not satisfied with getting the money, they had to eliminate an independent voice on what is ostensibly an independent library board.
At one point, my first thought was that voting against giving away the library’s money, which was not municipal appropriations by the way, was my finest hour in over a quarter-century’s service. But then I realized my finest hour was Oct. 23, 2004, when I was the first to speak in this room at the dedication of the new Middletown Library.
My legacy is this library, a legacy shared with key colleagues and supporters who planned and built it, and foremost among them is the director, Susan O’Neal. So, we forgive our tormentors, not for their benefit, but for our own so we can move on.
I will close with a paraphrase of Benjamin Franklin, who, on leaving the Constitutional Convention in 1787, was asked what type of government was being given the people. He told them, “You got a republic — if you can keep it.”
Randall Gabrielan
Middletown
Sunday, April 15, 2012
Former President Of The Middletown Library Board of Trustees, Randall Gabrielan To Be Honored At April 18th Meeting
by guest blogger Linda Baum
At its upcoming April 18th meeting, the Middletown Library Board will present former Board president and 25-year trustee Randall Gabrielan with a plaque commemorating his quarter century of service.
The presentation will be made at 7:00 p.m. at the Library’s main branch on New Monmouth Road in Middletown. Thereafter, a duplicate of the plaque will be on display at the Library.
In my March 19th post, I mentioned that the Board had voted in February to rename the Library’s New Jersey room in Mr. Gabrielan’s honor, but that the dedication required approval from the Township. I learned at the Board’s March 21st meeting that the Township has declined the request based on a policy not to dedicate any premises to living recipients. Or at least that was the reason given.
In my March 19th post, I also addressed the issues in the matter of Mr. Gabrielan’s resignation from the Board this February. To summarize, this was about a technical violation -- Mr. Gabrielan’s signature as both trustee and vendor on a purchase order for several history books. Had his signature as trustee been left off, the order would have been processed without it, and there would not have been an issue.
In his resignation letter, Mr. Gabrielan took the opportunity to express his love and dedication to our library, to commend its talented leadership, and to express pride in the accomplishments of the boards on which he has served.
Please mark your calendar for April 18th.
At its upcoming April 18th meeting, the Middletown Library Board will present former Board president and 25-year trustee Randall Gabrielan with a plaque commemorating his quarter century of service.
![]() |
| Randall Gabrielan |
In my March 19th post, I mentioned that the Board had voted in February to rename the Library’s New Jersey room in Mr. Gabrielan’s honor, but that the dedication required approval from the Township. I learned at the Board’s March 21st meeting that the Township has declined the request based on a policy not to dedicate any premises to living recipients. Or at least that was the reason given.
In my March 19th post, I also addressed the issues in the matter of Mr. Gabrielan’s resignation from the Board this February. To summarize, this was about a technical violation -- Mr. Gabrielan’s signature as both trustee and vendor on a purchase order for several history books. Had his signature as trustee been left off, the order would have been processed without it, and there would not have been an issue.
In his resignation letter, Mr. Gabrielan took the opportunity to express his love and dedication to our library, to commend its talented leadership, and to express pride in the accomplishments of the boards on which he has served.
Please mark your calendar for April 18th.
Sunday, March 25, 2012
Audio from the January 18th 2012 Meeting of the Middletown Library Board
by guest blogger Linda Baum
My March 19th post on this blog evoked a flurry of comments about the statements made by some library employees who attended the February 15th Library Board meeting. For the record, I don’t think anything inappropriate was said. Many who spoke during the public comments portion of the meeting expressed concern about the intentions of the newly-refigured Board, and some were critical of the new Township appointees’ behavior at the January 18th Board meeting. I talked about the tone of that meeting in my January 24th post on this blog, but have been late in getting you the audio recording.
Below is a 35-minute audio clip from the nearly 5-hour January 18th meeting. It is a recording of the Board’s discussion about service contracts and purchase resolutions. Two issues were central to the discussion. One issue concerned the normal January purchase of library materials and the exemption of these types of materials from purchasing laws. The other issue was whether or not an attorney should review these purchase resolutions and be present at Board meetings.
In large part, you will hear Library Director Susan O’Neal explaining the rules that govern library materials purchases and responding to new trustee Michael Convery’s questions.
If you don’t have 35 minutes, then skip to the last 5 minutes of the audio recording to hear the comments – by Lawrence Nelsen in particular – that resulted in public criticism of the new Board members.
(Unfortunately, there is no video-recording for the January meeting that would make it much easier to identify who is speaking. The first Library Board meeting to be video-recorded was the February 15th meeting.)
My March 19th post on this blog evoked a flurry of comments about the statements made by some library employees who attended the February 15th Library Board meeting. For the record, I don’t think anything inappropriate was said. Many who spoke during the public comments portion of the meeting expressed concern about the intentions of the newly-refigured Board, and some were critical of the new Township appointees’ behavior at the January 18th Board meeting. I talked about the tone of that meeting in my January 24th post on this blog, but have been late in getting you the audio recording.
Below is a 35-minute audio clip from the nearly 5-hour January 18th meeting. It is a recording of the Board’s discussion about service contracts and purchase resolutions. Two issues were central to the discussion. One issue concerned the normal January purchase of library materials and the exemption of these types of materials from purchasing laws. The other issue was whether or not an attorney should review these purchase resolutions and be present at Board meetings.
In large part, you will hear Library Director Susan O’Neal explaining the rules that govern library materials purchases and responding to new trustee Michael Convery’s questions.
If you don’t have 35 minutes, then skip to the last 5 minutes of the audio recording to hear the comments – by Lawrence Nelsen in particular – that resulted in public criticism of the new Board members.
(Unfortunately, there is no video-recording for the January meeting that would make it much easier to identify who is speaking. The first Library Board meeting to be video-recorded was the February 15th meeting.)
Monday, March 19, 2012
Award Presentation Honoring Randall Gabrielan Scheduled For March 21st Library Board Meeting, Has Been Postponed
By guest blogger Linda Baum
In a 2/16 blog post, I announced that the Library Board had
voted unanimously at its February 15th meeting to rename the
Library’s New Jersey room in honor of former Library trustee Randall Gabrielan
and to present him with a plaque at the Board’s March 21st meeting in
recognition of his 25 years of service.
Unfortunately, there is a snag. At its January 17th meeting, the Township
Committee passed a “naming” resolution (resolution number 12-069) which requires that the naming or dedication of any
Township premises be formally approved by the Township Committee via adoption
of a resolution.
The naming resolution was drafted
in response to another well-publicized matter – the memorial for the late
Daniel Piano that was established at Croydon Hall with the approval of former
Parks & Recreation Director Gregg Silva, but without prior knowledge and
consent of Township officials.
While the circumstances in that case are very different from those
supporting the room dedication, the naming resolution wording encompasses both.
I am told that Township officials are reviewing the matter,
but there has been no word yet to my knowledge, nor is there anything about
this on the agenda for the Township Committee meeting Monday night.
Since the wording on the plaque will be different depending
on whether or not the room is renamed, it has been necessary to postpone the
plaque order. Thus, the presentation originally
slated for March 21st must be re-scheduled. I will update you as I know more.
Since this post is bound to draw comments questioning why Mr. Gabrielan is so deserving considering the accusations you’ve read in the press, let me address that now. The press got it wrong. They missed the real issues and left readers with the impression of wrongdoing, but in truth there was none.
Mr. Gabrielan’s history books are a valuable and appropriate addition to the collection of many local libraries, including ours. By purchasing the books directly from the author, our Library avoided both the shipping costs and the surcharges typically assessed by distributors for these types of specialty books. Therefore, public money was spent responsibly.
Nor was this about profit, however small. Like the rest of us, Mr. Gabrielan deserves to earn something for his work. Neither Mr. Gabrielan’s honorary role as Monmouth County Historian nor his part-time position as executive director of the Monmouth County Historical Commission include book writing as part of their duties. That is something Mr. Gabrielan does on his own time, and it is part of the way he makes his livelihood.
This was about a signature. Since the Library purchases large volumes of materials year-round, the Board president and treasurer sign purchase orders as a matter of course. Both Board members’ signatures appeared on the purchase order that also included Mr. Gabrielan’s signature as the vendor for the sale of several books. Had the president’s signature been left off that purchase order, the order would have been processed without any issue with just the treasurer’s signature. I’m sure the mayor knows that, but he chose to make it an issue.
The actions of the Library’s former Board were in line with the spirit of the law, if not the letter. And as I see it, it is hardly enough to tarnish the reputation of someone of Mr. Gabrielan’s caliber. He is more than deserving of recognition for his contribution to our community and his years of dedicated service.
Tuesday, March 6, 2012
Middletown Library Board Meeting 2/15/12 - Video
It has taken a few weeks for this video of the Middletown Public Library Board of Trustees meeting to be posted to YouTube and to be honest I haven't had a chance to watch it in full just yet.
This meeting that took place on February 15, 2012, was the first Library Board meeting after the resignation of long time Board President Randall Gabrielan. Newly appointed member, Lawrence Nelsen, was voted to be the New President of the Board of Trustees.
It is very apparent from the video that the new Board of Trustee members aren't ready for prime time.
The newly appointed Board Attorney Armen McOmber, makes it clear to everyone in attendance, including the new appointees, that the new members of the Library Board don't know what they are doing and therefore when it comes to the conducting of meetings and then proceeds to conduct the meeting himself.
He decides than that he will need to attend meetings until this new Board is capable of conducting meetings on its own.
There were also a few very passionate members of the audience that rose during the public comments portion of the meeting to express their feels of displeasure about the wrong direction the Middletown Library system seems to be heading.
This meeting that took place on February 15, 2012, was the first Library Board meeting after the resignation of long time Board President Randall Gabrielan. Newly appointed member, Lawrence Nelsen, was voted to be the New President of the Board of Trustees.
It is very apparent from the video that the new Board of Trustee members aren't ready for prime time.
The newly appointed Board Attorney Armen McOmber, makes it clear to everyone in attendance, including the new appointees, that the new members of the Library Board don't know what they are doing and therefore when it comes to the conducting of meetings and then proceeds to conduct the meeting himself.
He decides than that he will need to attend meetings until this new Board is capable of conducting meetings on its own.
There were also a few very passionate members of the audience that rose during the public comments portion of the meeting to express their feels of displeasure about the wrong direction the Middletown Library system seems to be heading.
Thursday, February 16, 2012
Randall Gabrielan To Be Honored At The March 21st Meeting Of The Library Board
by Linda BaumAt last night’s Library Board meeting, the Board voted unanimously to present a plaque to former Board president and 25-year trustee Randall Gabrielan for his years of dedicated service and to rename the Library’s New Jersey room in his honor.
The New Jersey room is home to the many fine histories authored by Mr. Gabrielan, Monmouth County Historian, so it is a fitting tribute that the room should bear his name. A duplicate of the plaque will be on display at the Library.
The presentation will be made at the Board’s March 21st meeting at 7:00 p.m. at the Library’s main branch. Please mark your calendars and join me and many others in recognizing a lifetime of service and achievement.
Wednesday, February 15, 2012
It's Your Town - Video Newsletter 2/6/12
As I announce last month, the It's Your Town newsletter was going to be changing. It's author Don Watson, had decided that it was time to stop writing about what goes on at Township Committee meetings each month and start showing residents what actually happens during Township Committee meetings.
Mr. Watson has announced he will no longer be presenting the newsletter in its current form recapping Middletown Township Committee meetings as he has done for the past few years. Instead however, it is with great delight that he now will present video recordings of the Middletown Township Committee meetings
Below is the first video which he recorded held on Monday, February 6, 2012.
"... It was an impressive meeting to launch the first recording. The Middletown Swim and Tennis Club community showed up to make their case for keeping the club off the auction block. The mayor thanked the past president of the library board, Randall Gabrielan, for his years of service. This of course was after the mayor asked for Mr. Gabrielan’s resignation the previous week. Also, something that rarely happens, the Committee voted on each new resolution individually.", Mr. Watson stated in an email announcing the format change to subscribers of his newsletter.
It is hoped that this video starts a new era in Middletown, an era of transparency. This first recording shows what really goes on at Middletown Township Committee meetings. If readers of this blog take the time to watch this video and any videos that come later they will see and hear how our Township Committee deals with its citizens.
"... Current and previous Middletown Committees said the people who want meetings recorded have a political agenda. They said recording the meetings would cost too much. They said giving the public video access would allow them to grandstand. You decide if videotaping the meetings is worthwhile..., Finally, I want to extend my personal thank you to the many concerned citizens who made this recording possible with their support. By uniting we triumphed over those who said it couldn’t be done. Many thanks. And as always, thank you all for taking an interest in your local government.", stated Watson.
Don Watson will be offering the Township Committee a copy of this recording with the hope that they will post it on our Township’s public television access stations.
The video runs over two and a half hours, the first few minutes of the video you will hear a lot of noise. There are no guns being fired. It is a malfunction of the sound system.
As a companion to the video Mr. Watson has put together a PDF document that contains the meeting agenda and the resolutions that were voted on during the meeting. A box around an item is a link, bringing you further into the document to that resolution or ordinance. At the end of the resolution there will be a link bringing you back to the agenda. It is a little easier to follow along when you can see what is being voted on.
While watching the video pay attention to who speaks and who doesn't speak from the dais, Township Attorney Brian Nelson is sitting next to mayor Tony Fiore. Nelson is an appointed official, not an elected official, yet he speaks as if he is!
It should be pointed out that although Nelson isn't an elected official, he is a high ranking member of the Middletown GOP who makes a living off the taxpayers of the Township.
Watch closely for the arrogance and distain he shows for those that stand in front of the Committee. He rolls his eyes, laughs and snickers at the very residents that he makes his living off of.
Tuesday, February 14, 2012
January 18th meeting of the Middletown Library Board sets the tone for the year. The Demands, the Numbers, and the Possibilities Part 1
by guest blogger Linda Baum
This is my second post about the 1/18/12 Library Board meeting. See my January 24th post to read about the controversy over the Board’s leadership. A lot has happened since the January meeting, as you all know. Library Trustee Sherry Miloscia resigned from the Board for personal reasons effective January 20th. Trustee and Board President Randall Gabrielan resigned from the Board effective February 7th. Seven out of nine members remain, and the Township Committee now has majority control of the Board with 4 out of 7 votes. If they fill the two empty seats, the Township will have 6 out of 9 votes and a two thirds majority.
******
The January 18th meeting was the first for the newly expanded 9-member Board. The five new faces on the Board presented a challenge for Library Director Susan O’Neal, who is to be commended for responding to a great many questions with patience, good humor, and
Throughout the meeting, there was harsh, often aggressive criticism from the new Township appointees, who had clearly decided in advance what their collective approach would be. They seemed ready to air all of their complaints on day one. There wasn’t time for all of it at that meeting, but “just wait till the next meeting”, as an anonymous commenter on this blog warned.
The next Library Board meeting is this Wednesday, February 15th at 7:30 p.m. at the main branch on New Monmouth Road. I encourage you all to attend. (FYI, the meeting actually begins at 7:00 p.m., but the Board will go into closed session for about a half hour right after the meeting is called to order.)
Much was discussed at the January meeting, which ran almost 5 hours. Since there is incorrect information “out there”, I wanted to provide all the facts, making this my longest post by far. I organized topics by heading to make things easier for readers, and had to break up the post into three separate parts for the blog, each still long. This is part one.
THE PARKING LOT EXPANSION
Early in the meeting, it was announced that resources now exist for the parking lot expansion that was put on hold last year. The initial traffic study for the lot expansion has already been completed by Maser Consulting. The key parts of the project are improvements in safety (more lighting, traffic calming, crosswalks), more handicapped spaces, a drop off zone for short term parking, and additional parking spaces (approximately 35 more spaces).
The project is expected to cost roughly $122K-150K. Available monies include reserves, largely from expense savings that the Library was able to achieve last year, plus state aid monies.
Recall that per the 2011 agreement with the Township, the Library has two options for paying for capital improvements – they can pay cash or pay the debt service on bonds/notes issued by the Township. Libraries are not allowed to themselves issue debt, so the two payment options may not represent anything new. The Board has always preferred to save up until they have enough money for a project rather than to incur debt and pay interest. The Township does the opposite.
Also, the Library is now required to use the Township’s consulting engineer, T&M Associates, for any engineering work. T&M is not on retainer with the Township, so will bill for its services. Since the work is being directed to T&M without competitive bidding -- the Library Board would normally request bids/quotes for this job -- the cost could be higher than what the Library would otherwise pay.
THE POSSIBILITIES: “Restricting” about $150,000 in reserves for the lot expansion is to be discussed at the Board’s February 15th meeting. Since, by law, library reserves that are restricted for capital projects cannot be taken by the Township, the new trustees are sure to be opposed to it. I suspect they will make the case for allowing the Township to sell bonds/notes to raise money for the work. I suppose the new trustees could take a different tack and say the lot expansion isn’t necessary. However, part of the reason for the project is to improve safety, and I don’t think the Township would want to be seen as being against that.
Aside from leaving more reserves on the table for the Township’s use, the Township would benefit from the debt sale in several ways that I won’t get into here.
THE NUMBERS: If the Library pays cash for the lot expansion, their current budget will show the total cost of the project, or about $150,000. If the Library pays debt service, the budget for each of the next 20-25 years will show the lower debt service payment, say $15,000. The latter option results in a higher budget in future years, but a budget cut of about $135,000 for the current year.
A $135,000 cut in the Library budget increases the “take” by the Township by MORE than $135,000 -- by $162,000. Here’s why. Per law, the Library can keep a portion of its unrestricted reserves equal to 20% of its annual budget. If the budget is cut, that “frees up” some additional reserves on top of the amount cut from the budget. In short, for every $1 cut from the Library’s budget, the Township increases its take by $1.20. A CAVEAT: The new Board could vote to hand over 100% of the Library’s reserves to the Township. If so, then one dollar cut from the library’s budget is just one dollar of reserves available for the taking.
State aid monies are off limit to the Township, so would remain with the Library. Any restricted reserves are protected, but can always be unrestricted by a willing Board.
THE 2012 BUDGET
Ms. Murray objected to the 2012 budget being approved in December before the new Board came in and said that it should be re-opened.
Ms. O’Neal pointed out that the Township typically requires the Library Board to have the budget for a year in place by October of the prior year. The Township didn’t need the Library’s 2012 budget as early as usual, so the Board had a couple of extra months to incorporate more finalized information. So the December approval was later, not earlier, than usual. Ms. O’Neal emphasized that the budget was adopted in line with required procedure, not in anticipation of a different point of view, as has been suggested by anonymous commenters.
Board president Randy Gabrielan advised that the budget is a planning document only that is not written in stone.
And while it wasn’t said, the budget for a year is supposed to be ready before the start of that year -- that is the way most well run organizations do it, even if the Township doesn’t.
Because the January agenda was already full, Mr. Gabrielan suggested that a detailed discussion about finances be postponed until the February 15th Board meeting.
Marjorie Cavalier suggested that specific financial issues might be better handled by an ad-hoc committee. There was agreement that the Finance Committee would be reconstituted, and Ms. Murray will be on it.
This is my second post about the 1/18/12 Library Board meeting. See my January 24th post to read about the controversy over the Board’s leadership. A lot has happened since the January meeting, as you all know. Library Trustee Sherry Miloscia resigned from the Board for personal reasons effective January 20th. Trustee and Board President Randall Gabrielan resigned from the Board effective February 7th. Seven out of nine members remain, and the Township Committee now has majority control of the Board with 4 out of 7 votes. If they fill the two empty seats, the Township will have 6 out of 9 votes and a two thirds majority.
******
The January 18th meeting was the first for the newly expanded 9-member Board. The five new faces on the Board presented a challenge for Library Director Susan O’Neal, who is to be commended for responding to a great many questions with patience, good humor, and
expertise.
Throughout the meeting, there was harsh, often aggressive criticism from the new Township appointees, who had clearly decided in advance what their collective approach would be. They seemed ready to air all of their complaints on day one. There wasn’t time for all of it at that meeting, but “just wait till the next meeting”, as an anonymous commenter on this blog warned.The next Library Board meeting is this Wednesday, February 15th at 7:30 p.m. at the main branch on New Monmouth Road. I encourage you all to attend. (FYI, the meeting actually begins at 7:00 p.m., but the Board will go into closed session for about a half hour right after the meeting is called to order.)
Much was discussed at the January meeting, which ran almost 5 hours. Since there is incorrect information “out there”, I wanted to provide all the facts, making this my longest post by far. I organized topics by heading to make things easier for readers, and had to break up the post into three separate parts for the blog, each still long. This is part one.
THE PARKING LOT EXPANSION
Early in the meeting, it was announced that resources now exist for the parking lot expansion that was put on hold last year. The initial traffic study for the lot expansion has already been completed by Maser Consulting. The key parts of the project are improvements in safety (more lighting, traffic calming, crosswalks), more handicapped spaces, a drop off zone for short term parking, and additional parking spaces (approximately 35 more spaces).
The project is expected to cost roughly $122K-150K. Available monies include reserves, largely from expense savings that the Library was able to achieve last year, plus state aid monies.
Recall that per the 2011 agreement with the Township, the Library has two options for paying for capital improvements – they can pay cash or pay the debt service on bonds/notes issued by the Township. Libraries are not allowed to themselves issue debt, so the two payment options may not represent anything new. The Board has always preferred to save up until they have enough money for a project rather than to incur debt and pay interest. The Township does the opposite.
Also, the Library is now required to use the Township’s consulting engineer, T&M Associates, for any engineering work. T&M is not on retainer with the Township, so will bill for its services. Since the work is being directed to T&M without competitive bidding -- the Library Board would normally request bids/quotes for this job -- the cost could be higher than what the Library would otherwise pay.
THE POSSIBILITIES: “Restricting” about $150,000 in reserves for the lot expansion is to be discussed at the Board’s February 15th meeting. Since, by law, library reserves that are restricted for capital projects cannot be taken by the Township, the new trustees are sure to be opposed to it. I suspect they will make the case for allowing the Township to sell bonds/notes to raise money for the work. I suppose the new trustees could take a different tack and say the lot expansion isn’t necessary. However, part of the reason for the project is to improve safety, and I don’t think the Township would want to be seen as being against that.
Aside from leaving more reserves on the table for the Township’s use, the Township would benefit from the debt sale in several ways that I won’t get into here.
THE NUMBERS: If the Library pays cash for the lot expansion, their current budget will show the total cost of the project, or about $150,000. If the Library pays debt service, the budget for each of the next 20-25 years will show the lower debt service payment, say $15,000. The latter option results in a higher budget in future years, but a budget cut of about $135,000 for the current year.
A $135,000 cut in the Library budget increases the “take” by the Township by MORE than $135,000 -- by $162,000. Here’s why. Per law, the Library can keep a portion of its unrestricted reserves equal to 20% of its annual budget. If the budget is cut, that “frees up” some additional reserves on top of the amount cut from the budget. In short, for every $1 cut from the Library’s budget, the Township increases its take by $1.20. A CAVEAT: The new Board could vote to hand over 100% of the Library’s reserves to the Township. If so, then one dollar cut from the library’s budget is just one dollar of reserves available for the taking.
State aid monies are off limit to the Township, so would remain with the Library. Any restricted reserves are protected, but can always be unrestricted by a willing Board.
THE 2012 BUDGET
Ms. Murray objected to the 2012 budget being approved in December before the new Board came in and said that it should be re-opened.
Ms. O’Neal pointed out that the Township typically requires the Library Board to have the budget for a year in place by October of the prior year. The Township didn’t need the Library’s 2012 budget as early as usual, so the Board had a couple of extra months to incorporate more finalized information. So the December approval was later, not earlier, than usual. Ms. O’Neal emphasized that the budget was adopted in line with required procedure, not in anticipation of a different point of view, as has been suggested by anonymous commenters.
Board president Randy Gabrielan advised that the budget is a planning document only that is not written in stone.
And while it wasn’t said, the budget for a year is supposed to be ready before the start of that year -- that is the way most well run organizations do it, even if the Township doesn’t.
Because the January agenda was already full, Mr. Gabrielan suggested that a detailed discussion about finances be postponed until the February 15th Board meeting.
Marjorie Cavalier suggested that specific financial issues might be better handled by an ad-hoc committee. There was agreement that the Finance Committee would be reconstituted, and Ms. Murray will be on it.
Monday, February 6, 2012
Breaking News - Randall Gabrielan Resigns As President Of Middletown Library Board
It has come to my attention that Middletown Library Board of Trustees President Randall Gabrielan has sent a letter to Middletown mayor Tony Fiore and the Township Committee, stating his intentions of resigning his postion on theMiddletown Library Board of Trustees as a result of inappropriately signing off on purchase vouchers for a number of local history books written by him and that were directly sold through him, to the library.
In the letter sent to mayor Fiore, Gabrielan states, "... after the reading of a far-reaching interpretation in a decision of the Office of Administrative Law in a Local Finance Board case, I understand that signing vouchers for my minor sales constitutes a violation as the small amounts involved do not matter. Accordingly, I here by resign as president and trustee of the Middletown Township Public Library effective this date."
More on this news later....
In the letter sent to mayor Fiore, Gabrielan states, "... after the reading of a far-reaching interpretation in a decision of the Office of Administrative Law in a Local Finance Board case, I understand that signing vouchers for my minor sales constitutes a violation as the small amounts involved do not matter. Accordingly, I here by resign as president and trustee of the Middletown Township Public Library effective this date."
More on this news later....
Tuesday, January 31, 2012
Library Board Treasurer Sherry Miloscia Resigns
According to tonights article posted online at the Asbury Park Press, Middletown mayor wants library chief to resign for selling his own books to library, board treasurer Sherry Miloscia has resigned her position as Treasurer of the Middletown Library.
With Sherry Miloscia's resignation, it seems that Tony Fiore and the Middletown GOP have gotten what they wanted even if Randall Gabrielan doesn't resign his position. Once they appoint their hand picked replacement of Miloscia, they will have wrestled control away from the protectors of the library so that they will have free access to any and all surplus or reserved funds that the library may be able to accumulate for a rainy day and redirect it for their own purposes.
UPDATE :
The APP has edited it's story for the todays morning printed edition.
According to the APP, Miloscia resigned shortly after Tony Fiore sent his letter of wrong doing to the library board accusing Board President Randall Gabrielan of unethically and inappropriately selling books to the library and asking for his resignation as President of the Library Board of Trustees.
The APP's article has a little bit more information pertaining to the book sales in question that have been going on for the past several years and were apparently OK with the Township Committee because nothing was ever said or acted upon until know even with Committeeman Kevin Settembrino sitting on the the Library Board as the Mayor's Designee last year .
The article states:
Of each of the $20 to $30 books that the library purchased, Gabrielan said he ultimately received 40 percent. Of the $778.45, 40 percent would total $311.38.
With Sherry Miloscia's resignation, it seems that Tony Fiore and the Middletown GOP have gotten what they wanted even if Randall Gabrielan doesn't resign his position. Once they appoint their hand picked replacement of Miloscia, they will have wrestled control away from the protectors of the library so that they will have free access to any and all surplus or reserved funds that the library may be able to accumulate for a rainy day and redirect it for their own purposes.
UPDATE :
The APP has edited it's story for the todays morning printed edition.
As it turns out Sherry Miloscia DID NOT resign after Fiore sent his letter to the Library Board but resigned on on January 20th, which was before the letter was sent.
Below is the edited version appearing in print today:
On Jan. 20, a couple of days before Fiore sent his letter, board treasurer Sherry Miloscia resigned from her unpaid position, she said.
Miloscia, whose signature also appears on several of the invoices, did not comment beyond specifying when she resigned. Her term was due to expire at
On Jan. 20, a couple of days before Fiore sent his letter, board treasurer Sherry Miloscia resigned from her unpaid position, she said.
Miloscia, whose signature also appears on several of the invoices, did not comment beyond specifying when she resigned. Her term was due to expire at
the end of the year.
"Political Retaliation" In Play Against Middletown Library Board President
Middletown's acting Mayor Tony Fiore has asked the President of the Middletown Library Board to resign his position as Board President according to an article posted on Middletown-Patch this morning.
According to Middletown-Patch, a letter was sent to Library Board President Randal Gabrielan last Wednesday requesting his resignation for questionable inappropriate and unethical behavior pertaining to books purchased by the Middletown Library that were penned by Gabrielan.
Randal Gabrielan is the Monmouth County historian and writes books about the history of Monmouth County and its towns. The books are available at many book sellers throughout NJ.
Where the supposed ethical violations come into play in this case is that as Library Board President, Randal Gabrielan signs all the purchase vouchers for the library, including the vouchers that pertain to the books that he has written.
Randal Gabrielan states in the article that this is "political retribution" for his vocal stance opposing the Township's money grab of nearly $500,000 last year and for the failure of one of the Township Committee's hand picked, newly appointed Library Board of Trustees members not being able to dethrone him as Board President at the Library's January 18th Board meeting, which was the first board meeting after the Middletown Township Committee expanded the membership of the board from 7 members to 9 members to gain greater control over the library's finances.
According to Middletown-Patch, a letter was sent to Library Board President Randal Gabrielan last Wednesday requesting his resignation for questionable inappropriate and unethical behavior pertaining to books purchased by the Middletown Library that were penned by Gabrielan.
Randal Gabrielan is the Monmouth County historian and writes books about the history of Monmouth County and its towns. The books are available at many book sellers throughout NJ.
Where the supposed ethical violations come into play in this case is that as Library Board President, Randal Gabrielan signs all the purchase vouchers for the library, including the vouchers that pertain to the books that he has written.
To Fiore and Co., this is a major issue that requires Gabrielan to step down from his position, even though this has been going on for years with the knowledge and approval of the Township and the fact that the library would have purchased the books for its collection anyway.
Randal Gabrielan states in the article that this is "political retribution" for his vocal stance opposing the Township's money grab of nearly $500,000 last year and for the failure of one of the Township Committee's hand picked, newly appointed Library Board of Trustees members not being able to dethrone him as Board President at the Library's January 18th Board meeting, which was the first board meeting after the Middletown Township Committee expanded the membership of the board from 7 members to 9 members to gain greater control over the library's finances.
“This request for resignation is an act of political retaliation prompted by my opposition in 2011 to the Township Committee's demand that the library turn over surplus funds (which did not come from municipal appropriations) to the township and the failure of the mayor's new expanded library board of trustees to elect one of their number, none of whom has any library board experience, to the presidency of the board at the January 18th library board meeting,” According to Gabrielan’s statement posted on Middletown-Patch.
I think that before looking at Mr. Gabrielan, Tony Fiore should be looking closer to home for ethical lapses and request a certain Planning Board member to step down.....
Tuesday, January 24, 2012
Presidency of Middletown Library Board sought by new Board member; Proof of Politicalization
By guest blogger Linda Baum
Last Wednesday’s Library Board meeting (1/18/12) started at 7:00 p.m. and ran over four and a half hours. This was the first meeting of the new 9-member Board, five of whom are new appointees.
Sixteen members of the public attended the meeting, in whole or in part, and it was a veritable “who’s who” of the Republican Party. Among others, there were Committeeman and former Library Board member Kevin Settembrino, Committeeman and Deputy Mayor Steve Massell, Emil Wrede (TOMSA Board), James Hinkley (TOMSA Board), Tristen Nelsen (former Township Committee candidate), and some others sitting with them. I caught what I can only describe as “knowing” glances that told me many there were not strangers to each other. I leave to you to decide whether their purpose in attending was to support, to intimidate, or simply to be informed.
There were some regular folks at the meeting, too – we were discernable by our much more casual clothing.

Things began on a cordial note, with introductions and brief backgrounds. That was followed by a discussion of expenses and service contracts, which I’ll address in a separate post. Overall, the new Board members were very critical of Library operations, even accusatory.
When it was time for the election of 2012 officers, Ms. Sherry Miloscia presented the Nominating Committee’s recommendation of Mr. Randall Gabrielan as president, Ms. Vivian Breen as vice president, and Ms. Marjorie Cavalier as treasurer. There was no recommendation for the office of secretary because the original nominee, Ms. Rachel Raymond, the School Superintendent’s alternate for the prior year, was not reappointed to the Board for 2012. Ms. Miloscia found that out just five days before this meeting and had then contacted new Board member Lawrence Nelsen to offer him the role of secretary, but he turned it down, saying he didn’t feel qualified.
Committeewoman Stephanie Murray took issue with the use of a Nominating Committee – commonly used by many boards – and was fast to make her own nomination when informed that taking additional nominations from the floor was routine procedure. She started right at the top, recommending newcomer Lawrence Nelsen for president. She turned to him and said, “Would you do it? Would you do this?,” as if it had never been discussed. He agreed, of course, and didn’t seem surprised, but many of the public attendees were amazed at the audacity.
Ms. Miloscia asked Mr. Nelsen why he felt qualified to be president when he said he didn’t feel qualified enough to be secretary. Mr. Nelsen denied saying that. “Yes you did,” she replied.
Ms. Murray felt that a person with a financial background should be president -- Mr. Nelsen is an accountant. Others pointed out that the treasurer's position would be a good place for an accountant concerned with finances to start. The treasurer’s position was available, but Mr. Nelsen wasn’t interested in it.
The reasoning that the Board needs a president with financial experience is not supported if you consider that the Library Board drafted and approved a budget that, despite a reduction in the Township appropriation, still managed to maintain services, employment and most materials.
Something I think was being overlooked is that Board membership provides each trustee the opportunity to oversee operations, whether that person is an officer or not. That participation is precisely the reason given by the Township for expanding the Board.
New Board member Michael Convery asked, “Why do you think Larry can’t be president?” The experienced Board members explained that the position of president requires a lot of knowledge and a lot of time, and that the need to provide guidance to an inexperienced person would put an unfair burden on the Library Director. The many answers and lengthy explanations Ms. O’Neal was required to provide to the new members at this Board meeting is evidence of that.
In short, having an inexperienced person as Board president could hamper Library operations. Therefore, the new trustees did not appear to be acting in the best interest of the Library.
It was suggested that the new members could consult with any respected source, including the New Jersey Library Association, and would be told of the importance of experienced leadership.
I wondered what the president’s rights and responsibilities are that made the position so sought after. I have been provided this explanation:
The president is the first among equals as the Board's link to the Director on situations where library operations meet library policy, which is set by the Board. The president is the primary Board source for the Director on matters of economic, political, social, employment and legal concerns that impact the library. It is important that the president recognize and honor the distinction between the Trustee’s role of oversight and the Director's role of management and that the president not attempt to interfere in library operations. In order to fulfill this role, it is essential that the president be knowledgeable and experienced in these matters, qualities that have become even more important in today’s challenging environment.
Also, I am told that the president’s role at meetings is similar to the mayor’s -- he sets the tone and guides discussion but has an equal vote.
Ms. Breen pointed out to Ms. Murray that she would not expect to be mayor her first year as a committeewoman. She replied, “No, and I wouldn’t want to,” but seemed to miss the point that Mr. Nelsen was too inexperienced to be president.
The new Board members expressed concern about Mr. Gabrielan’s length of service as president, made reference to the size of the budget, and fell just shy of accusing him of wrong doing. The criticism was unfounded, in my opinion. It was an unfair attack on the character of a man who is well-regarded as a dedicated servant. But that accusatory tone underscored the meeting. Later on, Mr. Nelsen twice referenced Bernie Madoff. That comment offended many of us.
The new members also expressed some frustration with the materials they were provided and felt some information was missing. That drew a sharp response from the others, who asked what they were referring to. The Library Director did her best to explain the information provided and some differences between business in January and the other months of the year.
A woman sitting near me who was a former library employee felt strongly that the problem was that the new Board members were unfamiliar with library operations.
It seemed to me there was a lot of posturing going on by the new members. Last year the Library was villanized, and it seems the stage is being set for that again. I am reminded of that saying that the truth of an accusation doesn’t matter because the damage is done when the accusation is made.
Perhaps in an attempt to quell the accusation and argument, Ms. Breen suggested making Mr. Nelsen vice president. I thought that was a generous concession considering his lack of experience with library matters.
Mr. Convery asked if the election of officers needed to take place right then and was told that there was a need to have officers in place for financial matters and for continuity of operations. The Library’s by-laws call for elections at the January reorganization meeting because terms expire then. (Note that the Township Committee elects its officers in January as well.)
In the end, Mr. Gabrielan was elected president by a vote of 5 to 4. The four new Board members voted as a block for Mr. Nelsen. The deciding vote for Mr. Gabrielan was cast by new Board member Cynthia Wilson, the School Superintendent’s appointee.
While Mr. Convery said that his reason for wanting to delay the vote was to get to know people before voting, I wonder if that was his motive. Had the vote been delayed until the end of the meeting, for example, the outcome would have been different because two of the Board members who voted for Mr. Gabrielan didn’t stay for the whole meeting. Those early departures, at this meeting or any future meeting, change the make-up of the Board. Late arrivals or absences would have the same effect.
After the debate over the presidency, the other officers were selected quickly. Mr. Nelsen was elected vice president; Ms. Cavalier was elected treasurer, and Ms. Breen secretary – each held the same post last year.
As vice president, Mr. Nelsen will run meetings in the absence of Mr. Gabrielan, who has had a near perfect attendance record. Also, the VP title puts Mr. Nelsen in line for the presidency in 2013, when he is certain to get it because the new Board members will have the five votes they need next year with the Township’s replacement of Ms. Miloscia, whose term expires at the end of this year.
With one more voice, the Township’s new appointees will be able to elect to any office any candidate they choose, award contracts as they choose, make employment decisions, and unrestrict any amount of Library reserves for Township use.
Last Wednesday’s Library Board meeting (1/18/12) started at 7:00 p.m. and ran over four and a half hours. This was the first meeting of the new 9-member Board, five of whom are new appointees.
Sixteen members of the public attended the meeting, in whole or in part, and it was a veritable “who’s who” of the Republican Party. Among others, there were Committeeman and former Library Board member Kevin Settembrino, Committeeman and Deputy Mayor Steve Massell, Emil Wrede (TOMSA Board), James Hinkley (TOMSA Board), Tristen Nelsen (former Township Committee candidate), and some others sitting with them. I caught what I can only describe as “knowing” glances that told me many there were not strangers to each other. I leave to you to decide whether their purpose in attending was to support, to intimidate, or simply to be informed.
There were some regular folks at the meeting, too – we were discernable by our much more casual clothing.

Things began on a cordial note, with introductions and brief backgrounds. That was followed by a discussion of expenses and service contracts, which I’ll address in a separate post. Overall, the new Board members were very critical of Library operations, even accusatory.
When it was time for the election of 2012 officers, Ms. Sherry Miloscia presented the Nominating Committee’s recommendation of Mr. Randall Gabrielan as president, Ms. Vivian Breen as vice president, and Ms. Marjorie Cavalier as treasurer. There was no recommendation for the office of secretary because the original nominee, Ms. Rachel Raymond, the School Superintendent’s alternate for the prior year, was not reappointed to the Board for 2012. Ms. Miloscia found that out just five days before this meeting and had then contacted new Board member Lawrence Nelsen to offer him the role of secretary, but he turned it down, saying he didn’t feel qualified.
Committeewoman Stephanie Murray took issue with the use of a Nominating Committee – commonly used by many boards – and was fast to make her own nomination when informed that taking additional nominations from the floor was routine procedure. She started right at the top, recommending newcomer Lawrence Nelsen for president. She turned to him and said, “Would you do it? Would you do this?,” as if it had never been discussed. He agreed, of course, and didn’t seem surprised, but many of the public attendees were amazed at the audacity.
Ms. Miloscia asked Mr. Nelsen why he felt qualified to be president when he said he didn’t feel qualified enough to be secretary. Mr. Nelsen denied saying that. “Yes you did,” she replied.
Ms. Murray felt that a person with a financial background should be president -- Mr. Nelsen is an accountant. Others pointed out that the treasurer's position would be a good place for an accountant concerned with finances to start. The treasurer’s position was available, but Mr. Nelsen wasn’t interested in it.
The reasoning that the Board needs a president with financial experience is not supported if you consider that the Library Board drafted and approved a budget that, despite a reduction in the Township appropriation, still managed to maintain services, employment and most materials.
Something I think was being overlooked is that Board membership provides each trustee the opportunity to oversee operations, whether that person is an officer or not. That participation is precisely the reason given by the Township for expanding the Board.
New Board member Michael Convery asked, “Why do you think Larry can’t be president?” The experienced Board members explained that the position of president requires a lot of knowledge and a lot of time, and that the need to provide guidance to an inexperienced person would put an unfair burden on the Library Director. The many answers and lengthy explanations Ms. O’Neal was required to provide to the new members at this Board meeting is evidence of that.
In short, having an inexperienced person as Board president could hamper Library operations. Therefore, the new trustees did not appear to be acting in the best interest of the Library.
It was suggested that the new members could consult with any respected source, including the New Jersey Library Association, and would be told of the importance of experienced leadership.
I wondered what the president’s rights and responsibilities are that made the position so sought after. I have been provided this explanation:
The president is the first among equals as the Board's link to the Director on situations where library operations meet library policy, which is set by the Board. The president is the primary Board source for the Director on matters of economic, political, social, employment and legal concerns that impact the library. It is important that the president recognize and honor the distinction between the Trustee’s role of oversight and the Director's role of management and that the president not attempt to interfere in library operations. In order to fulfill this role, it is essential that the president be knowledgeable and experienced in these matters, qualities that have become even more important in today’s challenging environment.
Also, I am told that the president’s role at meetings is similar to the mayor’s -- he sets the tone and guides discussion but has an equal vote.
Ms. Breen pointed out to Ms. Murray that she would not expect to be mayor her first year as a committeewoman. She replied, “No, and I wouldn’t want to,” but seemed to miss the point that Mr. Nelsen was too inexperienced to be president.
The new Board members expressed concern about Mr. Gabrielan’s length of service as president, made reference to the size of the budget, and fell just shy of accusing him of wrong doing. The criticism was unfounded, in my opinion. It was an unfair attack on the character of a man who is well-regarded as a dedicated servant. But that accusatory tone underscored the meeting. Later on, Mr. Nelsen twice referenced Bernie Madoff. That comment offended many of us.
The new members also expressed some frustration with the materials they were provided and felt some information was missing. That drew a sharp response from the others, who asked what they were referring to. The Library Director did her best to explain the information provided and some differences between business in January and the other months of the year.
A woman sitting near me who was a former library employee felt strongly that the problem was that the new Board members were unfamiliar with library operations.
It seemed to me there was a lot of posturing going on by the new members. Last year the Library was villanized, and it seems the stage is being set for that again. I am reminded of that saying that the truth of an accusation doesn’t matter because the damage is done when the accusation is made.
Perhaps in an attempt to quell the accusation and argument, Ms. Breen suggested making Mr. Nelsen vice president. I thought that was a generous concession considering his lack of experience with library matters.
Mr. Convery asked if the election of officers needed to take place right then and was told that there was a need to have officers in place for financial matters and for continuity of operations. The Library’s by-laws call for elections at the January reorganization meeting because terms expire then. (Note that the Township Committee elects its officers in January as well.)
In the end, Mr. Gabrielan was elected president by a vote of 5 to 4. The four new Board members voted as a block for Mr. Nelsen. The deciding vote for Mr. Gabrielan was cast by new Board member Cynthia Wilson, the School Superintendent’s appointee.
While Mr. Convery said that his reason for wanting to delay the vote was to get to know people before voting, I wonder if that was his motive. Had the vote been delayed until the end of the meeting, for example, the outcome would have been different because two of the Board members who voted for Mr. Gabrielan didn’t stay for the whole meeting. Those early departures, at this meeting or any future meeting, change the make-up of the Board. Late arrivals or absences would have the same effect.
After the debate over the presidency, the other officers were selected quickly. Mr. Nelsen was elected vice president; Ms. Cavalier was elected treasurer, and Ms. Breen secretary – each held the same post last year.
As vice president, Mr. Nelsen will run meetings in the absence of Mr. Gabrielan, who has had a near perfect attendance record. Also, the VP title puts Mr. Nelsen in line for the presidency in 2013, when he is certain to get it because the new Board members will have the five votes they need next year with the Township’s replacement of Ms. Miloscia, whose term expires at the end of this year.
With one more voice, the Township’s new appointees will be able to elect to any office any candidate they choose, award contracts as they choose, make employment decisions, and unrestrict any amount of Library reserves for Township use.
Tuesday, February 15, 2011
Quote of the Day From Middletown
Today's quote of the day in Middletown is in response to the Township Committee stating that police layoffs can be averted if only the Middletown library hands over it's surplus funds:
"I don't really think there is a link between library funds and police positions, they just believe it is politically convenient for them to make one.'' - Randall Gabrielan, President of the Middletown Library Board of Trustees
Source Asbury Park Press 2/15/11
"I don't really think there is a link between library funds and police positions, they just believe it is politically convenient for them to make one.'' - Randall Gabrielan, President of the Middletown Library Board of Trustees
Source Asbury Park Press 2/15/11
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

