Showing posts with label Midddletown Board of Education. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Midddletown Board of Education. Show all posts
Sunday, September 30, 2018
Board of Education Voting Meeting - 9/26/18: Tony Perry Tries and Fails To Make A Deal And Shows How Little He Understands
I just finished watching the video from this past Wednesday night’s Middletown Board of Education (BOE) Meeting. What started out as a nice night of recognition for teachers and administrators involved in the school district being awarded 'Future Ready Silver Certification' (a distinction, given to only 35 schools in NJ, 17 of which Middletown is one), ended in what can only be characterize as a desperate attempt to gain some recognition as a candidate for Township Committee by the school community, from Middletown Committeeman Tony Perry, who is up for election this November.
It seems Middletown’s Board of Education isn’t the only entity in our community not immune to political stunts this election season.
When the meeting was opened for Public Comments, the unelected Committeeman and Candidate, Tony Perry (who, by the way was appointed by his Father In Law, Gerry Scharfenburger to the Township Committee), took to the microphone 'On Behalf of the Township Committee' to address the BOE regarding a possible agreement to take over the maintenance of 'Bayshore Elementary'.
A couple of quick notes before moving on; First, wasn't there just a conference held by Mayor Kevin Settembrino, where he proclaimed that he alone spoke for the TC, which would mean that either Settembrino sanctioned Mr. Perry's visit to speak on behalf of the committee and make an offer or Tony Perry was going rogue, trying to make deals on his own, even though he is not a member of the joint Shared Services Committee. Later in his comments, he seems to back away from this statement and declared he 'doesn't speak on behalf of anyone, but himself'. Secondly, there is no 'Bayshore Elementary ', he would know that if he lived in Middletown for more than 5 minutes before becoming a Township Committeeman and not attempting an obvious political stunt, so I will assume he is referring to Bayview Elementary School.
Moving on ... Perry made reference to the potential Stevenson's Park Sports Complex, which in his words, 'is a political football' and 'not an honest discussion of how many fields would be placed there.' He goes on to accuse others (presumably, his opponents, one of which is Board Member Danielle Walsh) of 'intentionally misleading the residents of Shady Oaks and Shadow Lake'. Honestly, I'm not sure what these statements were meant to accomplish at a BOE meeting other than an attempt to garner votes by driving a wedge between the BOE and the parents of a few sports kids.
You can call me crazy if you want, but according to the plans for the sports complex that I and others have seen, they clearly show a plan to create a total of 9 multi-purpose sports fields beginning with a Phase 1 start of 2 fields.... Again, call me crazy, but how does informing residents living adjacent to Stevenson Park of plans for a potential Sports Complex by others 'intentionally misleading' or relevant in any way to the BOE?
He then offered to propose on 'behalf of the Township Committee' to take over control and maintenance responsibilities for Bayview Elementary Fields. In return, the Township Committee would decide which entities are entitled to use of the fields, with the school events getting priority. Not a bad deal for the BOE, right? Except, Board President Joan Minnuies pointed out, the Township Committee already decides who gets priority over these fields. He went on to refer to Bayview as an 'unknown and treasured part of Middletown.' Unknown? Really? I’m sure thousands of Belford residents would be shocked to know their elementary school was unknown to a candidate for the Township Committee.
Committeeman Perry also asserted that in the arrangement, the 2 baseball fields presently there (albeit without pitchers mounds because they are multi-purpose fields) , would be torn down to make room for the maintenance of soccer, flag football and lacrosse fields. When BOE member Michael Donlon questioned this, Perry inferred that it would be fine because there were no issues with lack of field time for baseball in Middletown.
BOE member, Danielle Walsh questioned his political motivations for addressing the BOE, since he 'had never been to a Board of Education Meeting before tonight' and 'suggested what would amount to an agenda item for Shared Services'. And further took issue with Mr. Perry's accusation that the BOE 'ignored' their fields. It was at this point that Mr. Perry changed his tune and insisted he was there speaking 'on behalf of himself', then went on to say 'I don't have the ability to have my voice heard to the School Board on my opinions about Shared Services decisions that occur. Unfortunately, that is why I have to come to these meetings.'.
BOE member Nick DiFranco also took issue with some of Mr. Perry's assertions regarding Shared Services and the extent to which the BOE was involved in addressing issues with field usage.
The bottom line here is that Mr. Perry, accompanied by another unelected Committeeman, Rick Hibell (who did not speak) seemed out of his depth of knowledge when it came to not only how the BOE works, but how to effectively communicate within the boundaries of his own Township Committee. But this is what you get when you have a Township Committee where there is no accountability to the point of blatant nepotism. Watch the exchange in the video for yourself and decide (I’ve queued it to the start of Perry’s comments).
Other than what I’ve mentioned above, the Voting Meeting was relatively uneventful (with the exception of Board Member Leonora Caminitti referring to another BOE member as a 'sissy'), but you should still take the time to watch the entire meeting, which you can access …. HERE
And while you’re at it do me a favor, consider asking the BOE to work on their video sound quality. I appreciate the transparency of the taped meetings, but the execution leaves a lot to be desired.
Saturday, September 29, 2018
Interesting Question, Is Middletown Being PILOT'ed ?
Over on the Facebook group, Stop Village 35, the Admin there added an interesting post yesterday asking if the town is engaging in the PILOTing of Middletown. Until reading this post I had know idea what this alleged PILOT program entailed.
PILOT is an anachronism for Payment In Lieu Of Taxes and is essentially a huge give away to developers in return for cash payments directly benefiting Town Hall. According to the Stop Village 35 post 95% of these payments would go to the municipality, 5% to the county and 0% would be given to the Board of Education. Which means that both Monmouth County and Middletown's Board of Education(BOE) are cut out of potential vast amounts of tax dollars that should be rightfully owed to them. For the BOE this would mean that Middletown's children and the quality of their education is at risk because of under funding and could then lead to higher school taxes being imposed to make up the difference.
The post goes into further detail about what the PILOT program is and its potential ramifications for Middletown, if in fact this is what's happening behind the scene. It also hints at my Thursday post concerning the inflated cost of the new municipal complex that is in development.
The Stop Village 35 Facebook page is closed to the general public, you need to be a member of the group to see any of it's posts so I've copied it and have added it below for people who can't access the page to read. It really is a fascinating read and should be alarming to residents.
IT’S TIME TO TAKE BACK OUR TOWN. Fund the Fight, Save Middletown: http://bit.ly/Save07748
WHAT OUR TOWN OFFICIALS AREN’T SAYING: Redevelopment designation and PILOT (Payment In Lieu of Taxes) go hand-in-hand. They don’t want to talk about their possible deal with the Circus Liquors Redevelopment Developers; nor do they legally have to disclose a PILOT deal at this point.
Here’s a juicy nugget that might explain why our Township Committee gave it all away to the developer — the possibility of a PILOT program. The biggest effect of a PILOT program is how payments are disbursed: 95% to the municipality, 5% to the county, 0% to the schools. OK, this means the Board of Education loses out, the quality of our kids’ education is compromised, and our property values are screwed. Quality of education is a huge factor in property values.
Funding for the Municipal Complex, Town Hall, is rumored at $54 million to build. This is relevant to the following explanations of Areas in Need of Redevelopment, applicable PILOT programs, and revenue that is reaped by the municipality. This is complicated, but it’s important!
By designating a site an Area in Need of Redevelopment, the municipality may enter into a PILOT (Payment In Lieu Of Taxes) agreement with the developer. Archer Law offers a clear explanation of NJ PILOT programs: http://bit.ly/PILOT_explained
“Instead of property taxes, developers make an annual PILOT payment to the municipality. The PILOT payment is typically much less than traditional taxes, and is structured so that the municipality receives more of a benefit than it would from usual property taxes. Not only do these exemptions save a developer in real estate taxes, but they provide an increase in the fair market value of the property as a result of higher net operating income.
Long-term tax abatements may last up to 30 years from the completion of a project, are typically utilized for larger redevelopment projects, and require a municipality to declare an area as being in need of redevelopment....The PILOT structure...greatly reduces the developer’s tax burden, and results in significant savings over the term of the PILOT agreement.”
Effects of PILOT programs:
PILOT programs may last as long as 30 years from completion of project, or 35 years from date agreement is signed; minimum term is 10 years.
PILOT program payments are disbursed 95% to the municipality, 5% to the county, 0% to the schools. School taxes are the greatest single portion of tax bills in Middletown. In some cases, the property may already have been paying school tax, but under PILOT, that obligation would be removed.
PILOT amounts often exceed the revenue municipalities would have received from taxes, while, at the same time, denying funding to school districts.
PILOT programs artificially depress rateable property tax base.
IT’S TIME TO TAKE BACK OUR TOWN. Fund the Fight, Save Middletown: http://bit.ly/Save07748
Sunday, June 10, 2018
BOE Voting Meeting - 5/23/18
I haven't watched this video of the May 23rd, 2018 meeting of the Middletown Board of Education just yet but I intend to do so soon. It's only an hour long so there are no excuses (haha).
You can find the various Agendas for this meeting ..... HERE
Other videos from previous meeting can be found .... HERE
Friday, March 30, 2018
March 20, 2018 BOE Workshop Meeting
I'm about halfway thru watching this video from the March 20th workshop meeting of the Middletown Board of Education (BOE). I'm posting it now because the video from Wednesday night's March 28th meeting will be posted soon. People should get caught up with the current video if possible before watching the one that will be posted to the Middletown Board of Education YouTube channel.
It was during this meeting that the BOE presented an overview of the new 2018/2019 FY School Budget that would be voted on at the March 28th meeting, which included funds for additional security officers and school improvements.
The various meeting agendas for this meeting can be found on the BOE's website.
It was during this meeting that the BOE presented an overview of the new 2018/2019 FY School Budget that would be voted on at the March 28th meeting, which included funds for additional security officers and school improvements.
The various meeting agendas for this meeting can be found on the BOE's website.
Wednesday, December 28, 2016
Paff: Middletown taxpayers must reimburse teachers pension fund $3.8 million.
From time to time I've posted press releases from the NJ Foundation for Open Government (NJFOG) and when appropriate I've reposted from the John Paff blogs, "Random notes on NJ government" and "NJ Open Government Notes". John Paff and NJFOG advocate for open and transparent government and work to ensure that government agencies are following OPRA and OPMA laws.
Besides being an advocate for open government, John Paff also writes about noteworthy issues and recent court cases on his blogs, that bring to light issues that may normally be overlooked.
One such case that might have gone over overlooked if it weren't for John Paff writing about last week was a December 22, 2016, decision of the NJ Appellate Court, that stated the Middletown Board of Education must reimburse its pension fund $3.8 million for passing out unapproved "illegal" early retirement incentives to school district employees in 2007.
Last week, during the rush leading up to Christmas, a time when a story like this can be easily missed, the Middletown Patch picked-up on it and word began to spread.
I first saw the Patch article posted on Facebook a December 23rd and made a mental note to myself to go back later and read any comments. I later shared John Paff's blog post to the Middletown New Jersey Facebook page. It has since been shared 17 times and has dozens of reactions and comments.
Reprinted here is John Paff's original posting from his blog "Random notes on NJ government":
An appeals court today affirmed a ruling requiring the Middletown Board of Education (Monmouth County) to reimburse its pension fund $3,815,600 for offering Board employees an "illegal" early retirement incentive.
According to the Appellate Division's December 22, 2016 opinion, the Middletown school board approved a "sidebar agreement" with the local teachers union on October 22, 2007 that offered tenured teachers who retired or resigned prior to June 30, 2008 $225 for each unused sick day up to a maximum of $40,000. The agreement similarly offered non-certified union members $125 per sick day up to a maximum of $20,000.
The next day, an Audit Supervisor with the Division of Pensions and Benefits, who had heard about the offering, said that the offering needed to be reviewed by the Division and asked the Board for specific information which the Board provided on November 5, 2007. By then, five teachers and a secretary had exercised their rights under the sidebar agreement.
On August 1, 2008, the Division informed the Board that the early retirement benefit was "impermissible" and directed the Board to "provide a final list of all individuals" that had taken advantage of it so that a Division actuary could "develop the acceleration cost of this incentive which in turn will be billed to [the Board]." Although the Board responded to the Division on August 11, 2008, the Division did not get back to the Board until February 6, 2014. On that date, the Division informed the Board that it was "responsible for the additional pension liabilities created" by its unauthorized early retirement incentive. The Division calculated the present value of those pension liabilities at $5,429,900 and invoiced the Board for that amount.
The Board appealed the Division's decision and invoice to Teachers' Pension and Annuity Fund (TPFA) Board of Trustees. On December 14, 2014, the TPFA affirmed the Division's ruling that the early retirement incentive was illegal but reduced the assessment to $3,815,600 and allowed the Board to pay that amount over a five year period at no interest.
The Board filed another appeal which was resolved by the TPFA's March 13, 2015 written decision. That decision held that 41 employees ultimately took advantage of the sidebar agreement's early retirement incentive and that those early retirements burdened the pension fund.
The Appellate Division rejected the Board's appeal of the TPFA's ruling. The court found that the Board "approved the Sidebar Agreement without consulting the Division or obtaining approval and then implemented the Sidebar Agreement after receiving a letter from the Division stating approval was required before such a plan could be implemented." The court also noted that the Board failed to provide any actuarial evidence to contest the findings of the Division's actuary.
Keep in mind that this case is nearly 10 years old. Other than Joan Minnuies, no other current BOE member was there at the time, that of course, will change when Lenora Caminiti rejoins the BOE when it reorganizes next month. She was there as well back in 2007 and her and Joan Minnuies have some explaining to do.
Now the questions are; What does the newly constituted 2017 Middletown Board of Education do about this issue and what will the plan for reimbursing the pension fund be? At this time it's anyone's guess. I'm sure there are or will be intense discussions going on.
I would hope that whatever decision is made, it will be the least disruptive to taxpayers and repayment spread out over a reasonable amount of time. The last thing I'd like to see however would be some sort of bond issue to repay the pension fund. That would only cost taxpayers more in the long run with fees and interest.
Wednesday, December 21, 2016
BOE Voting Meeting - December 13, 2016: Legal Fees Controversy
I finished watching the latest recording of the Middeltown Board of Education meeting late Monday afternoon and needed some time to post it to the blog, so that I could process what I had finished watching. And it's good that I did. The Asbury Park Press posted two articles about what transpired during the meeting which saves me a lot of time trying to explain it myself:
Posted online Monday was, "7 highlights from Middletown schools' audit", which pointed out some very good news for the district:
I would like to see some of that savings "banked" for a rainy day because I know theater are things coming down the line that will cost the district big time over the next couple of years.
The other article posted yesterday, "Middletown school board hires outside lawyers for ethics dispute", however is what gave me pause and the need to think before posting about what I had experienced after watching the BOE video. During a 20 minute discussion (triad really) beginning at 1:12:00 mark of the video, Middletown Board of Education disfunction once again raised it's ugly head.
In essence, a last minute item was added to the night's Agenda that many Board members weren't fully aware of. That item was for the approval of the hiring of the law firm of Giordano, Halleran & Cielsa, PC as special counsel to represent 5 Board members in connection with the several ethic complaints they filed against fellow member Joan Minnuies, some of which has been dismissed, while some others have been bumped up to OAL litigation.
For this representation, the school district will be paying any legal bills associated with the litigation of the 5 individual Board members, Vinnie Brand, Bob Banta, Ernest Donnelly, Michael Donlon and BOE president Jim Cody at the rate of $250/hour for litigation counsel and $100/hour for paralegal/legal assistant time with NO cap on the fees!
When the items was being introduced, Board member Sue Griffin made a motion to table the item until the following meeting, when the new BOE could discuss it further and decide whether it was appropriate or not to continue. After a heated argument between Griffin, Brand and Cody erupted about due diligence of board members still sitting on the Board and what was actually stated in the legal agreement that was to be voted on, the board went into executive session to discuss the item further.
Again you can watch the whole exchange staying at the 1:12:00 minute mark of the video.
In my opinion, this is outrageous and utter waste of tax payers money. If the School Ethics Board dropped some other charges against Joan Minnuies but couldn't decide on others and referred them for OAL litigation to pass the buck so to speak, then the charges aren't worth pursuing if it means that it could cost the district tens of thousands of dollars! And that's not easy for me to say, I'm not a big Joan Minnuies fan. All this comes down to now is a very expensive, personal vendetta against Minnuies by her fellow board members - two of which, Brand and Banta, will no longer be members of the board, when legal action will proceed and representation will be needed sometime next year.
If action does move forward on this now frivolous legal action, than I think Vinnie Brand and Bob Banta should have to pay for their own legal expenses since they will no longer be members of the Board of Education.
There has also been outrage expressed by some Middletown residents HERE and HERE on Facebook over this.
But, as Board president Jim Cody stated during the video, there's nothing really to worry about. No money from the school budget will be allocated for legal fees. The cost of legal fees will come out of the BOE's Legal Services budget. HA-HA, ain't that great! It's all one and the same to me.
I would expect that once the new Board takes control next month this issue will be looked at once again and the correct decision will be made to kill this nonsense once and for all.
Posted online Monday was, "7 highlights from Middletown schools' audit", which pointed out some very good news for the district:
Revenues
Property taxes
- $206,501,974: This figure includes all the money that flows into the district, most of which is property taxes. In 2015, total revenues were $192.8 million.
Expenses
- $137,004,630: The township schools are the single-biggest contributor to the bottom line on your property tax bill. The district collected about $4 million more from homeowners in 2016, an increase of 3 percent from the previous year. Local taxes make up 76 percent of the public money that fund Middletown schools.
Teacher compensation
- 206,168,208: Transportation was one area that shot up. Getting students to and from school cost $10.8 million, or $866,000 more than in 2015.
Enrollment
- $75,592,658: The cost of instruction increased by less than 1 percent from 2015. The $570,000 in new money went to negotiated salary increases and a handful of new positions. The certified teaching staff was counted at 922.
Cost per pupil
- 9,698: For some perspective, 10 years ago the district had 427 more students in class on an average day. There are 12.6 pupils for every teacher. The national average is about 16 to 1, according to the National Center for Education Statistics.
Debt
- $16,510: This represents the highest amount the district has ever spent, but it's still relatively low. The average district in New Jersey was paying close to $20,000 for each student in the 2014-2015 school year, according to the Taxpayers Guide to Education Spending.
- $68,920,000: That's down $3.8 million from the previous year. The district's bond rating remains at "AA", which is the second-highest rating that Standard & Poor's assigns. Generally speaking, the higher the rating, the less it costs to borrow money. About 4 percent of district spending goes to paying down debt and interest.
I would like to see some of that savings "banked" for a rainy day because I know theater are things coming down the line that will cost the district big time over the next couple of years.
The other article posted yesterday, "Middletown school board hires outside lawyers for ethics dispute", however is what gave me pause and the need to think before posting about what I had experienced after watching the BOE video. During a 20 minute discussion (triad really) beginning at 1:12:00 mark of the video, Middletown Board of Education disfunction once again raised it's ugly head.
In essence, a last minute item was added to the night's Agenda that many Board members weren't fully aware of. That item was for the approval of the hiring of the law firm of Giordano, Halleran & Cielsa, PC as special counsel to represent 5 Board members in connection with the several ethic complaints they filed against fellow member Joan Minnuies, some of which has been dismissed, while some others have been bumped up to OAL litigation.
For this representation, the school district will be paying any legal bills associated with the litigation of the 5 individual Board members, Vinnie Brand, Bob Banta, Ernest Donnelly, Michael Donlon and BOE president Jim Cody at the rate of $250/hour for litigation counsel and $100/hour for paralegal/legal assistant time with NO cap on the fees!
When the items was being introduced, Board member Sue Griffin made a motion to table the item until the following meeting, when the new BOE could discuss it further and decide whether it was appropriate or not to continue. After a heated argument between Griffin, Brand and Cody erupted about due diligence of board members still sitting on the Board and what was actually stated in the legal agreement that was to be voted on, the board went into executive session to discuss the item further.
Again you can watch the whole exchange staying at the 1:12:00 minute mark of the video.
In my opinion, this is outrageous and utter waste of tax payers money. If the School Ethics Board dropped some other charges against Joan Minnuies but couldn't decide on others and referred them for OAL litigation to pass the buck so to speak, then the charges aren't worth pursuing if it means that it could cost the district tens of thousands of dollars! And that's not easy for me to say, I'm not a big Joan Minnuies fan. All this comes down to now is a very expensive, personal vendetta against Minnuies by her fellow board members - two of which, Brand and Banta, will no longer be members of the board, when legal action will proceed and representation will be needed sometime next year.
If action does move forward on this now frivolous legal action, than I think Vinnie Brand and Bob Banta should have to pay for their own legal expenses since they will no longer be members of the Board of Education.
There has also been outrage expressed by some Middletown residents HERE and HERE on Facebook over this.
But, as Board president Jim Cody stated during the video, there's nothing really to worry about. No money from the school budget will be allocated for legal fees. The cost of legal fees will come out of the BOE's Legal Services budget. HA-HA, ain't that great! It's all one and the same to me.
I would expect that once the new Board takes control next month this issue will be looked at once again and the correct decision will be made to kill this nonsense once and for all.
Thursday, October 30, 2014
Cliff Notes From Oct. 27th BOE Meet The Candidates Forum
I couldn't attend the Oct. 27th Middletown Board of Education Meet The Candidates Night, hosted by the Harmony Elementary School PTO because I had to work. Fortunately for me (and you), my friend Roxanne did attend and sent me her notes from the evening which appear below (keep in mind that her notes are not transcripts from the evening, they are NOTES).
I found Roxanne's notes very helpful and I wish to thank her for taking the time to type them out and send them to me to share. I hope that those that read this post will find her notes as helpful in determining who to vote for on Tuesday as I have.
Opening Statements:
Christopher J. Aveta – resident of Middletown for 10 years, 2 kids in M‐town schools, lawyer. Was previously on the BoE and served as chair of finance committee, instrumental in curricula and tech updates, progress began when he was elected in 2010, hopes to be elected again.
Mark Bouthillette – 13 years in district, 3 kids in schools now, former Marine Corps, carpenter, worked with IT/Webhosting company for Merrill Lynch, feels connected with district, team player
Ernest Donnelly – 40 year resident, passion is education, was an educator – teacher, vice principal, principal and superintendent, chairman of the tech committee, wants to make improvements in safety
Sue Griffin – 17 yrs in district, 4 children went through schools, president of the BoE now, 3rd year on the board, been serving in some capacity since 2000, 2 most important aspects of her job – the children and tax payers’ money
Helen A. Henkel – 23 year resident, 2 kids went through M‐town, service back to the community important to her, RN that works with children with cleft palate, able to work with families, professionals due to this experience
Question and Answer portion:
Question 1. What are the educational gaps or weaknesses in Middletown schools?
Aveta – mainly in elementary school, gaps in grammar, spelling, need continuity of instruction in the formative years
Donnelly – articulation necessary for all levels especially with 17 schools, listen to teachers and parents for feedback
Griffin – Chair of the curriculum committee, feels language arts and writing and also handwriting are issues
Henkel – need to know what the impact of the Common Core standards will be for our students, civics education lacking
Bouthilette – Core Curriculum implementation is key, working together with BoE, admin, staff and families
Aveta – language arts scores and interpretation need to be discussed with teachers. Parents confused about how their children are doing.
2. Common Core – opinion of? Viable for Middletown to opt‐out?
Bouthilette – mandated by state, need to implement, it does take away from face‐to‐face teaching time, but we need to find a way to make it fit with our town
Aveta – it’s here, cannot opt out of a state mandate, needs to be addressed by parents and staff together
Donnelly – Follow the rules and regs of the state mandate, common core was put together by teachers and researchers, already spent $ to prepare for Common Core and PARCC testing, let’s see results first, adapt it to help us
Griffin – opening up a discussion with teachers, need to make it a continual conversation
Henkel – not a proponent of Common Core, not sure if we should wait to see long term results since it might not work, encouraged people to contact legislators about making changes
3. Leading concern among special needs parents in Middletown?
Donnelly – always seeking to improve educational opportunities, listen to parents, constant communication, help bridge special and regular ed
Aveta – parents and students want to be heard, need the least restrictive environment possible
Henkel – communication to be open at all times, adapting education to that child, not adapting child to the education, advocacy for children and parents
Bouthillette – 100% for inclusion classes Griffin – looking at each child individually
Donnelly – inclusion for special needs, try to keep students in district at all costs
Henkel – we’re all part of the same team and we need to remember that
4. With a potential debt/deficit looming over the next year, how will you deal with a substantial loss to the budget?
Bouthillette – supplying the best education possible is our goal – esp preparing students for a global market, make collective decisions, cannot promise that taxes will stay the same.
Donnelly – we’re capped at a 2% budget increase, need to review all accounts and programs – perform an audit to see what is working and what can be cut.
Aveta – Chair of finance in the 3 years he served, had a surplus, the $5.5 million deficit was caused by state, need to have a contingency plan if that debt comes to fruition, questions some employee practices like early retirement
Henkel – properties that are owned and unused by the district should be assessed and sold off, check out administrative costs and potentially cut there

Griffin – look over budget and see what parents/community wants/needs
Donnelly ‐ $5 mil debt is a surprise to everyone, state is seeking money from 7 years back, want to ensure that we can still provide same quality education
5. Budgeting for future construction/maintenance costs?
Aveta – submitting any grants possible, see where we are before asking public to help subsidize, moving forward will need to have to do it better
Bouthillette – work going on now is only phase 1
Donnelly – neglected facilities was his cause when he initially ran for the BoE, successfully installing new roofs and boilers and these will last for years, also continuing the maintenance supervision to ensure a huge undertaking doesn’t need to occur again
Griffin – putting together a long‐range facilities plan – 5 y ear plan, keeping track of current issues and conditions
Henkel – Regular maintenance key, also need to check to see if we really need more buildings –unnecessary storage structure that cost $300,000?
Aveta – continue to make smart decisions going forward
6. What about the redistricting issue?
Bouthillette – not an easy process, would need community involvement for sure, also need a long‐range plan
Aveta – hardest sell is in the elementary schools where people feel the most community, what would be best for all residents?
Donnelly – currently have undertaken a “strategic plan” for the district that will be looking 10 to 15 years out. No one will redistrict until that plan is reviewed. What would be right for students/schools?
Griffin – need to hear from the community, also the strategic planning committee needs to report out, information is on the website – wants input from everyone in the Middletown community
Henkel – it’s everyone’s responsibility to shape the Middletown school district, not just BoE and educators, if we pay for it, we should be making the decisions
7. Describe an effective Board Member
Griffin – present, active listener and participant, willing to compromise, don’t take things personally
Donnelly – communicator, listener, respectful, solve problems, not micromanaging a district, listen to recommendations from admin

Aveta – involved, respectful of other’s views, ask questions, compromise
Henkel – advocate for the children, need to leave personal attacks aside, compromise, gather information
Bouthillette – team player, work with colleagues, input from rest of BoE, make decisions based on the facts, not personal beliefs
8. How can there be a more transparent and open culture in Middletown schools?
Bouthillette – the BoE is a liaison between the community and the education system, need community members to go to meetings, bring info to attention of the BoE members
Aveta – wants participation from community members all of the time, not just when big issues arise
Donnelly – Hiring a competent superintendent that can work with everyone is important, need to find someone who is willing to work with BoE and admin
Henkel – be open to all communications, willing to talk
Griffin – always sees the same people at meetings, inviting more to speak out and attend, always willing to talk
9. What is your educational philosophy?
Griffin – every child should be able to perform at their best at all times, not everyone will be an A student, but everyone can achieve in their own way
Aveta – every student should have the best opportunity to achieve at their best ability
Donnelly – continue to help students strive to improve, increase level of rigor each year
Henkel – everyone should be able to meet/exceed their dreams, meet every concern of every parent/student
Bouthillette – best education possible to make this the best community possible, afford our students the opportunities to be successful later in life
Closing statements:
Henkel –open to contact, serving the community of students and parents, CHILDREN FIRST and everything else takes a back seat to them
Griffin – Fighting for children to continue to learn, thrive and grow
Donnelly – takes education seriously, proud to serve, keeps himself involved on variety of meetings, need a united, equal opportunity Middletown
Bouthillette – passionate about Middletown and the ed opportunities, brings a diverse background, team player, progress of all, willing to take time to better himself by going to training

Aveta – Wants to continue to serve his community, wants to learn from mistakes of past, ability to compromise and works well with others
Tuesday, March 11, 2014
The Votes Are In, Referendum Passes
Tonight's Middletown Board of Education voter referendum passed by a resounding margin.
Yes - 2951 71.82%
No - 1158 28.18%
The election results can be view on the Monmouth County Clerk's website... HERE
Yes - 2951 71.82%
No - 1158 28.18%
The election results can be view on the Monmouth County Clerk's website... HERE
Friday, March 7, 2014
New Video: Interview at High School South with Dr. George on the Referendum
A new video was posted online yesterday at the Middletown Board of Education website featuring Middletown School Superintendent, Dr. William George. This video was produced by the students of Middletown High School South TV Production club.
There isn't much new information in this video. However, Dr. George addresses two rumors circulating about the referendum:
1. Does the district have discretion on what the referendum funds can be used for.
2. Will the referendum, if approved, lead to a redistricting of the school system.
According to Dr. George neither rumor is true. The funds from the referendum can only be used for and will only be used for the upgrading of building facilities around he district.
High School South TV Production club interviews Dr. George about the upcoming Voter Referendum
There isn't much new information in this video. However, Dr. George addresses two rumors circulating about the referendum:
1. Does the district have discretion on what the referendum funds can be used for.
2. Will the referendum, if approved, lead to a redistricting of the school system.
According to Dr. George neither rumor is true. The funds from the referendum can only be used for and will only be used for the upgrading of building facilities around he district.
High School South TV Production club interviews Dr. George about the upcoming Voter Referendum
Sunday, March 2, 2014
Election Update: Board of Education Voter Referendum
I'm still not sure how I will be voting on this. After reading some comments posted online by people who had attending the Board of Education's public information meetings concerning this referendum, I'm leaning towards voting NO. But as I said, I'm not sure just yet.
From Middletown Alerts:
Voting on the referendum will take place from 4 p.m. - 9 p.m. on Tuesday, March 11, 2014. At the January 28th voting meeting, the Board of Education approved a voter referendum to issue $19.3 million in bonds to address critical facilities needs. The remainder of the $32.2 million cost of these projects will be funded by $12.9 million in state grants. Sample ballots have been sent out by Monmouth County. Registered voters should receive them next week. If you would like to vote by mail please contact the Township Clerk’s Office at townclerk@middletownnj.org or 732-615-2015 for more information.
Wednesday, July 31, 2013
For those interested in the fate of the Lincroft Library building.....
At tonight's Special Meeting of the Board of Education taking place at 6:30pm at the August T. Miner (Board of Ed) Administrative building on Leonardville Road, the board plans to enter into a five year lease agreement with the township for use of the Lincroft Library building for administrative offices, leasing the building for just $1 per year to the township.
In reading the lease, it is not clear what administrative offices would be housed in the building, and whether Crossroads drug rehab counseling center is outside of the allowed use, seeing how Crossroads is in the process of vacating Croydon Hall to move there. Furthermore, the Lincroft community was not given the opportunity to collaborate with the Board of Education on the use of the building, as Dr. George had promised would happen. Members of the community felt strongly that if they were going to lose the library then they would want the future use to be in line with what was lost, i.e., for the building to have an educational use that benefits the children. While the Board of Education may not have an educational purpose for this building now, they may have one later. A shorter term lease should be given and then the use of the property could re-assessed in a new budget year.
It would seem that the residents and students of Lincroft all lose out on this deal. Educational enrichment, clubs, community center, etc..... are all possibilities that could be of benefit to students and the community. How does leasing the building for the township's administrative offices benefit any students other than those who will be attending the all girl "Catholic" school, Trinity Hall? Did they even think in a progressive way at all or reach out to non-profits, Brookdale, or other educational entities to see if there would be a better fit for the building or community? Apparently not.
You would think that after constantly being reminded by the Township Committee that 62% of all taxes collected in Middletown goes to the Board of Education and that is why our taxes are sooo high, the Board of Eduction would want to off set those taxes in someway by leasing the building to someone that would pay more than $1 per year. Again, apparently not.
The agenda and property agreement to lease the Lincroft Library to the Township can be found - HERE
(Thanks to M.E. for the heads up)
In reading the lease, it is not clear what administrative offices would be housed in the building, and whether Crossroads drug rehab counseling center is outside of the allowed use, seeing how Crossroads is in the process of vacating Croydon Hall to move there. Furthermore, the Lincroft community was not given the opportunity to collaborate with the Board of Education on the use of the building, as Dr. George had promised would happen. Members of the community felt strongly that if they were going to lose the library then they would want the future use to be in line with what was lost, i.e., for the building to have an educational use that benefits the children. While the Board of Education may not have an educational purpose for this building now, they may have one later. A shorter term lease should be given and then the use of the property could re-assessed in a new budget year.
It would seem that the residents and students of Lincroft all lose out on this deal. Educational enrichment, clubs, community center, etc..... are all possibilities that could be of benefit to students and the community. How does leasing the building for the township's administrative offices benefit any students other than those who will be attending the all girl "Catholic" school, Trinity Hall? Did they even think in a progressive way at all or reach out to non-profits, Brookdale, or other educational entities to see if there would be a better fit for the building or community? Apparently not.
You would think that after constantly being reminded by the Township Committee that 62% of all taxes collected in Middletown goes to the Board of Education and that is why our taxes are sooo high, the Board of Eduction would want to off set those taxes in someway by leasing the building to someone that would pay more than $1 per year. Again, apparently not.
The agenda and property agreement to lease the Lincroft Library to the Township can be found - HERE
(Thanks to M.E. for the heads up)
Friday, June 21, 2013
Taking Crossroads to Lincroft
Last week I posted how Trinity Hall, the all girls "catholic" school, demanded that Middletown remove Crossroads, the Middletown substance abuse service from its long time home at Croydon Hall by June 30th as part of Trinity's $285K lease agreement.
At the time of the posting it wasn't clear where within the township Crossroads could relocate to. It had been rumored that the program would be moved to the old Bayshore Branch of the Middletown Library located in Port Monmouth, since it was township property and Middletown was relocating the Recreation Department and a couple of other services that were housed at Croydon Hall there. That idea was scrapped however when it was learned that the building has structural issues and is too small to provided private counseling areas for the individuals and families that use Crossroads services. So, where will Crossroads be relocated to? It seems that the Township has approached the Middletown Board of Education (BOE) and has requested that Crossroads be relocated to the former Lincroft Branch of the Middletown Library. The BOE owns this build and it has sat empty since the library closed back in April when the Middletown Library Board of Trustees decided to close its satellite branches due to budget constraints . The BOE has pledged to lease the building to the township for just $1.
Now don't get me wrong, I'm happy to hear that the township has found a new home for Crossroads and the substance abuse services that it provides, but there are a few issues with moving Crossroads that can affect its moving to Lincroft:
1st off, the building in general, needs a lot of work - work that the libray was gearing up to fix before Tony Fiore and his cronies put their fingers into the til and swipped the library's surpluses.
2nd, the interior of the building needs to be remodeld to provide private office space for counselors and other social service workers.
3rd, I'm told that the service contracts of the various counselors are very specific due to state and federal grant money need to fund Crossroads. The counselors can not just move to a new location. The new location needs to be approved by the state before a move could be possible and the counselor's service agreements/contracts need to be amended and approved before they can counsel individuals or families. And what happens with those individuals who are currently performing community service at as a result of drug and alcohol legal offenses, who are currently working at Croydon Hall, helping out at the Senior Center? You just can't change the terms of their court ordered community service
4th, the building is located directly across from the Lincroft Elementary School. If Trinity doesn't want Crossroads at Croydon Hall how will Lincroft parents feel when they find out that Crossroads and those it services will be directly across the street from where their kids are going to school? I doubt they'll like it very much.
So the questions I have in my mind are as follows:
Who's paying for the building upgrades? The BOE, the Township or Crossroads? What are the legal ramifications of moving Crossroads from Croydon Hall? How will the BOE react if/when school parents start bitching about Crossroads moving in across the street? And what's up with the integrity of School Superintendent Dr. George? He personally assured a number of Library supporters that before anything is done with the Lincroft building the BOE would hold discussions with library advocates and school groups to determine the best possible use of the facility before any decisions about the build were made. Obviously that hasn't happened.
Middletown needs Crossroads and the substance abuse services that the program provides, it should not be moved. It needs to stay where it is. If /when it does move, it has to be done in timely fashion, it can't be rushed to meet Trinity's unrealistic June 30th time frame.
![]() |
| Crossroads at Croydon Hall |
Now don't get me wrong, I'm happy to hear that the township has found a new home for Crossroads and the substance abuse services that it provides, but there are a few issues with moving Crossroads that can affect its moving to Lincroft:
1st off, the building in general, needs a lot of work - work that the libray was gearing up to fix before Tony Fiore and his cronies put their fingers into the til and swipped the library's surpluses.
2nd, the interior of the building needs to be remodeld to provide private office space for counselors and other social service workers.
3rd, I'm told that the service contracts of the various counselors are very specific due to state and federal grant money need to fund Crossroads. The counselors can not just move to a new location. The new location needs to be approved by the state before a move could be possible and the counselor's service agreements/contracts need to be amended and approved before they can counsel individuals or families. And what happens with those individuals who are currently performing community service at as a result of drug and alcohol legal offenses, who are currently working at Croydon Hall, helping out at the Senior Center? You just can't change the terms of their court ordered community service
![]() |
| Lincroft Library |
So the questions I have in my mind are as follows:
Who's paying for the building upgrades? The BOE, the Township or Crossroads? What are the legal ramifications of moving Crossroads from Croydon Hall? How will the BOE react if/when school parents start bitching about Crossroads moving in across the street? And what's up with the integrity of School Superintendent Dr. George? He personally assured a number of Library supporters that before anything is done with the Lincroft building the BOE would hold discussions with library advocates and school groups to determine the best possible use of the facility before any decisions about the build were made. Obviously that hasn't happened.
Middletown needs Crossroads and the substance abuse services that the program provides, it should not be moved. It needs to stay where it is. If /when it does move, it has to be done in timely fashion, it can't be rushed to meet Trinity's unrealistic June 30th time frame.
Tuesday, June 4, 2013
Video: Middletown BOE Rehires Harmony Principal 5/21/13
This is old news but I promised to post video from the May 21st meeting of the Middletown Board of Education. It was at this meeting that the board made the unprecedented decision to reverse its prior decision to not rehire Harmony School principal Mr. Erik Paulson.
The BOE's earlier, unexplainable decision not to rehire Mr. Paulson against a stellar job performance review by School Superintendent Dr. William George, sparked anger and a major backlash against the BOE from the parents of Harmony School and its PTO.
This first video is of the public comments portion of the meeting where several people spoke on Mr. Paulson's behalf (but not before similar pleas were made to rehire district special education teacher Mr. Dilworth). Interestingly, in anticipation of those comments board president Chris Aveta, addressed those in attendance, compelled I suppose, to discuss Paulson's previous rehirings. Dr. George also spoke a few words about Mr. Paulson's situation before the floor was opened.
Mid-way through the comments, board member Jim Cody interrupted the proceedings and asked his fellow BOE members for a vote to enter into Executive Session to discuss the situation. Surprisingly, after the board was locked 4-4, board president Aveta broke from his colleagues who had initially voted against Paulson's rehiring and voted in favor of entering into Executive Session.
After being in Executive Session for over an hour, the second video shows BOE Attorney Mr. Parton addressed the audience to discuss what had happened in session, stating that new information concerning Mr. Paulson was brought to the attention of board members and because of the this new information the board would vote again on whether or not to rehire Mr. Paulson. The BOE then voted unanimously to do so. The floor was then opened back up to finished the public comments portion of the meeting that had been interrupted earlier
At the 9:05 mark of the second video a Mrs. Gyher (not sure of the spelling), who I believe was a district faculty member, scolded board president Aveta for his wrong and misleading remarks on school tenure (which many believe was behind the decision not to rehire Mr. Paulson). Mrs Gyher pointed out that it was not impossible to fire a teacher today and tenure was not for life as stated. Aveta backtracked slightly stating that it has been or would be to expensive or cost prohibitive for the district to fire a teacher so essentially tenure was for life (or something close to that effect).
The BOE's earlier, unexplainable decision not to rehire Mr. Paulson against a stellar job performance review by School Superintendent Dr. William George, sparked anger and a major backlash against the BOE from the parents of Harmony School and its PTO.
This first video is of the public comments portion of the meeting where several people spoke on Mr. Paulson's behalf (but not before similar pleas were made to rehire district special education teacher Mr. Dilworth). Interestingly, in anticipation of those comments board president Chris Aveta, addressed those in attendance, compelled I suppose, to discuss Paulson's previous rehirings. Dr. George also spoke a few words about Mr. Paulson's situation before the floor was opened.
Mid-way through the comments, board member Jim Cody interrupted the proceedings and asked his fellow BOE members for a vote to enter into Executive Session to discuss the situation. Surprisingly, after the board was locked 4-4, board president Aveta broke from his colleagues who had initially voted against Paulson's rehiring and voted in favor of entering into Executive Session.
After being in Executive Session for over an hour, the second video shows BOE Attorney Mr. Parton addressed the audience to discuss what had happened in session, stating that new information concerning Mr. Paulson was brought to the attention of board members and because of the this new information the board would vote again on whether or not to rehire Mr. Paulson. The BOE then voted unanimously to do so. The floor was then opened back up to finished the public comments portion of the meeting that had been interrupted earlier
At the 9:05 mark of the second video a Mrs. Gyher (not sure of the spelling), who I believe was a district faculty member, scolded board president Aveta for his wrong and misleading remarks on school tenure (which many believe was behind the decision not to rehire Mr. Paulson). Mrs Gyher pointed out that it was not impossible to fire a teacher today and tenure was not for life as stated. Aveta backtracked slightly stating that it has been or would be to expensive or cost prohibitive for the district to fire a teacher so essentially tenure was for life (or something close to that effect).
Monday, March 18, 2013
Independent Article On $1.2M Increase In School Budget Gives Potential Insight Into This Year's Municipal Budget
Last week's Independent had an article about the Middletown Board of Education's budget introduction for the upcoming 2013-2014 school year," Decline in property values drives M’twn school tax hike; $78M loss in property valuations contributes to $1.2M tax levy increase", this article may give us some insight into what this year's municipal budget may have in store for us. I recommend reading the article, it went into great detail explaining how the budget for the upcoming school year was put together and what were the priorities. You can then take a look at the Budget Presentation that the school administrators put together for its introduction that took place back on February 27th.
On Wednesday night this week (March 20th), the Middletown Board of Education will hold a public hearing on the budget, after which a vote will take place for its adoption.
Here's a snippet from the Independent article:
The only issue that I have with this article and the budget presentation is it states that the tax levy will increase by $1.2M due to the loss of $78M in property values caused by Hurricane Sandy. However, it does not give us the exact percentage of the increase, only saying that it keeps this years tax levy below the state mandated 2% cap. Based on my calculations that's correct, I figure the increase to be ~ 1.5%, which is fine. I just wish that the people putting this stuff together treated their intended audience as grown-ups and not children, you'll see what I mean when you examine the presentation.
The presentation goes to great length to explain how well the administrators have done over the past 3 years staying within the parameters of the mandated cap, using that argument to justify this years increase. I find this type of justification nauseating. I'd feel better about it if the school administration just stated the facts and not try to tippy-toe around the truth of the situation, which is, thanks to the damage caused by Hurricane Sandy throughout the township, property values are down and the school district can't make any further cuts to the upcoming budget without severely effecting the education of our kids.
Knowing that the loss of township property values is now at $78 million (as per the school budget) and the costs to clean up after Hurricane Sandy is in the millions of dollars, some of but not all of which, will be reimbursed at some point by the federal government and knowing that this years municipal budget should still be in the neighborhood of $65 million as in previous years, supported by a tax levy of nearly $45 million, I don't see how this year's budgeted tax increase will be below the state mandated 2% cap on property taxes.
Last year's tax cap increase was 1.97% and seeing how nothing significant has changed, we can use that as the baseline for this year's increased. Add to it an increase in the cost to health-care and other benefits along with all the clean-up costs associated with Hurricane Sandy and the $78 million hit taken from lost property values, I'd say that Middletown is looking at a budget increase of nearly 5% or more on top of our baseline, making this years increase in the neighborhood of 7% or potentially greater.
If this year's increase to the tax levy is going to be greater that 2% we should know within the next month or so. Middletown will need to ask its residents to approve the budget increase on Primary Day, June 4th.
On Wednesday night this week (March 20th), the Middletown Board of Education will hold a public hearing on the budget, after which a vote will take place for its adoption.
Here's a snippet from the Independent article:
MIDDLETOWN — Declining property values throughout Middletown contributed significantly to the tax levy increase in this year’s district Board of Education budget.
Proposed at the Feb. 28 board meeting, the $147,856,250 budget represents a tax levy increase of $1,250,042 over last year, which would account for a $68.90 annual hike for residents with a home valued at the township average of $375,500.
That increase is offset, however, by a decrease in the district’s annual debt service payments caused by recent refinancing. The total taxpayer increase would stand at $53.24 per year, or $4.44 per month.
According to board professionals, much of the increase is due to the loss of $78 million in township tax assessment valuations throughout the past year....
The only issue that I have with this article and the budget presentation is it states that the tax levy will increase by $1.2M due to the loss of $78M in property values caused by Hurricane Sandy. However, it does not give us the exact percentage of the increase, only saying that it keeps this years tax levy below the state mandated 2% cap. Based on my calculations that's correct, I figure the increase to be ~ 1.5%, which is fine. I just wish that the people putting this stuff together treated their intended audience as grown-ups and not children, you'll see what I mean when you examine the presentation.
The presentation goes to great length to explain how well the administrators have done over the past 3 years staying within the parameters of the mandated cap, using that argument to justify this years increase. I find this type of justification nauseating. I'd feel better about it if the school administration just stated the facts and not try to tippy-toe around the truth of the situation, which is, thanks to the damage caused by Hurricane Sandy throughout the township, property values are down and the school district can't make any further cuts to the upcoming budget without severely effecting the education of our kids.
Knowing that the loss of township property values is now at $78 million (as per the school budget) and the costs to clean up after Hurricane Sandy is in the millions of dollars, some of but not all of which, will be reimbursed at some point by the federal government and knowing that this years municipal budget should still be in the neighborhood of $65 million as in previous years, supported by a tax levy of nearly $45 million, I don't see how this year's budgeted tax increase will be below the state mandated 2% cap on property taxes.
Last year's tax cap increase was 1.97% and seeing how nothing significant has changed, we can use that as the baseline for this year's increased. Add to it an increase in the cost to health-care and other benefits along with all the clean-up costs associated with Hurricane Sandy and the $78 million hit taken from lost property values, I'd say that Middletown is looking at a budget increase of nearly 5% or more on top of our baseline, making this years increase in the neighborhood of 7% or potentially greater.
If this year's increase to the tax levy is going to be greater that 2% we should know within the next month or so. Middletown will need to ask its residents to approve the budget increase on Primary Day, June 4th.
Friday, November 9, 2012
It's Trunk or Treat on Sunday Then It's Back To School On Monday
The following notification came via email earlier today but it does not mention that Middletown schools will be back in session Monday 11/12:
In place of door to door Trick or Treating the Township of Middletown and Board of Education will be running "Trunk or Treat" on Sunday, November 11 in the afternoon as a safe Halloween alternate for the children of Middletown at the following elementary schools. Children are invited to all schools for this event no matter what school they attend, including all parochial and private school students. Children of all ages including those who not yet of school age, are invited to their neighborhood Trunk or Treat.
· Harmony 1-3 pm
· Ocean Avenue 1-3 pm
· Lincroft 1-3 pm
· New Monmouth 2-4 pm
· River Plaza 1-3 pm
· Bayview 3-5 pm
· Middletown Village 1-3 pm
· Nut Swamp 12-2 pm
· Leonardo 1-3 pm
· Fairview 1-3 pm
· Navesink approximately 2-3 pm following the Halloween parade at the Navesink firehouse
· Port Monmouth students who missed their event are invited to Ocean Avenue’s event.
According to the Middletown Township Board of Education website, township schools will reopen Monday, canceling the Veterans Day previously planned closure.
You can read all about it... Here
In place of door to door Trick or Treating the Township of Middletown and Board of Education will be running "Trunk or Treat" on Sunday, November 11 in the afternoon as a safe Halloween alternate for the children of Middletown at the following elementary schools. Children are invited to all schools for this event no matter what school they attend, including all parochial and private school students. Children of all ages including those who not yet of school age, are invited to their neighborhood Trunk or Treat.
· Harmony 1-3 pm
· Ocean Avenue 1-3 pm
· Lincroft 1-3 pm
· New Monmouth 2-4 pm
· River Plaza 1-3 pm
· Bayview 3-5 pm
· Middletown Village 1-3 pm
· Nut Swamp 12-2 pm
· Leonardo 1-3 pm
· Fairview 1-3 pm
· Navesink approximately 2-3 pm following the Halloween parade at the Navesink firehouse
· Port Monmouth students who missed their event are invited to Ocean Avenue’s event.
According to the Middletown Township Board of Education website, township schools will reopen Monday, canceling the Veterans Day previously planned closure.
You can read all about it... Here
Wednesday, June 20, 2012
Middletown BOE Withholding Diplomas From MHSS Co-Class-Presidents
Middletown High School South Co-Class Presidents Eric Dominach and Mike Sebastiano, are being threatened with the withholding of their diplomas by the Middletown Board of Education(BOE)for given an unapproved speech during graduation ceremonies last week.
The speech has been deemed somewhat inappropriate and is being called "bullying" by the BOE because Dominach and Sebastiano mentioned fellow classmates and made comments about administration and school culture.
This incident was brought to my attention this morning by a fellow classmate of theirs who wished to remain anonymous but who provided a Facebook link to a video of the speech, which you can watch HERE if you have a Facebook account.
My initial reaction to the speech after seeing the video is that it was a playful attempt at saying good-bye to friends and faculty with a little inside humor and wittiness. It was somewhat enjoyable to listen to; it was cleverly done and by the reaction of those in attendance seemed to go over well.
Was it as bad or inappropriate as the BOE may think? I don't think so, it was two kids talking to their friends in a way that kids do today, with references to POP culture and texting shorthand.
Is the BOE over reacting slightly? Yes and No. I understand that members of the BOE and some school faculty/administrators are upset that Dominach and Sebastiano went ahead on their own and delivered a speech that was not approved of by those in charge and rightfully so, they are taking action to send a message. But what these kids did wasn't, in my opinion, viscous, vindictive or mean spirited in anyway and it certainly wasn't bullying.
I say that the BOE should mail these guys their diplomas and be done with it, why create a mountain out of a mole hill? Why give parents and students anymore reasons to disagree with the actions of the BOE then they need to, seeing how many of the decisions made in the past year have been somewhat questionable.
I'm sure that the message has been sent, loud and clear, to future class presidents that they need to abide by the wishes of those in charge and not deliver a speech that wasn't first approved.
Make the announcement at tonight's Board of Education meeting (7:00 at MHSN) that they will be receiving their diplomas and be done with it.
*******************************
UPDATE 4:45pm
According to Facebook page "Operation Get Eric and Mike a Diploma" - Eric Dominach posted the following message about 40 minutes ago:
The speech has been deemed somewhat inappropriate and is being called "bullying" by the BOE because Dominach and Sebastiano mentioned fellow classmates and made comments about administration and school culture.
This incident was brought to my attention this morning by a fellow classmate of theirs who wished to remain anonymous but who provided a Facebook link to a video of the speech, which you can watch HERE if you have a Facebook account.
My initial reaction to the speech after seeing the video is that it was a playful attempt at saying good-bye to friends and faculty with a little inside humor and wittiness. It was somewhat enjoyable to listen to; it was cleverly done and by the reaction of those in attendance seemed to go over well.
Was it as bad or inappropriate as the BOE may think? I don't think so, it was two kids talking to their friends in a way that kids do today, with references to POP culture and texting shorthand.
Is the BOE over reacting slightly? Yes and No. I understand that members of the BOE and some school faculty/administrators are upset that Dominach and Sebastiano went ahead on their own and delivered a speech that was not approved of by those in charge and rightfully so, they are taking action to send a message. But what these kids did wasn't, in my opinion, viscous, vindictive or mean spirited in anyway and it certainly wasn't bullying.
I say that the BOE should mail these guys their diplomas and be done with it, why create a mountain out of a mole hill? Why give parents and students anymore reasons to disagree with the actions of the BOE then they need to, seeing how many of the decisions made in the past year have been somewhat questionable.
I'm sure that the message has been sent, loud and clear, to future class presidents that they need to abide by the wishes of those in charge and not deliver a speech that wasn't first approved.
Make the announcement at tonight's Board of Education meeting (7:00 at MHSN) that they will be receiving their diplomas and be done with it.
*******************************
UPDATE 4:45pm
According to Facebook page "Operation Get Eric and Mike a Diploma" - Eric Dominach posted the following message about 40 minutes ago:
We have Received our diplomas due to large support from the community and no complaints about our speech. I would like to thank everyone who said they would come support us. It really mean a lot and I am proud to say I graduated today. Thank you all.
Monday, June 13, 2011
I Wonder If This Affects Anyone Currently Sitting On Middletown's Board of Education or Applicants?
Seeing how there is a vacant seat currently on the Middletown Board of Education and that the Board is currently accepting application to fill that seat, I wonder how many applicants or current board members know about a bill recently signed into law by Governor Christie, creating tighter restrictions on eligibility requirements of those that serve on New Jersey school boards.
Journalist Mark Spivey recently wrote about this in a column that appeared on various news outlets around the area titled "Member might lose BOE seat; Faces disqualification from '68 drug charge"
I wonder how many current, past or future candidates for the BOE have long buried skeletons in their closets from their youthful indiscretions; Potentially there are many, but should it really preclude them from serving on the board now or in the future after so many years have past? After all, the same standard isn't applied to those seeking public office.
Journalist Mark Spivey recently wrote about this in a column that appeared on various news outlets around the area titled "Member might lose BOE seat; Faces disqualification from '68 drug charge"
...The bill “permanently disqualifies from employment or service” on those boards anyone who has been convicted of a wide range of crimes, including all first- and second-degree offenses (among them many drug-related offenses) but also more minor charges including criminal mischief, reckless endangerment or resisting arrest....
According to the bill, each of the nearly 5,000 members of New Jersey’s hundreds of boards of education is required to undergo a comprehensive criminal history and background check within 30 days. Board members are responsible for covering the cost of the background checks out of their own pockets.
Locally based Assemblyman Jerry Green, D-Union, explained that the bill mirrors existing state restrictions on public schools’ hiring practices.
“If we prohibit someone from teaching in a classroom because of past convictions, then they definitely should be prohibited from presiding over the education of an entire school district,” Green said. “It’s a commonsense change that is long overdue.”
I wonder how many current, past or future candidates for the BOE have long buried skeletons in their closets from their youthful indiscretions; Potentially there are many, but should it really preclude them from serving on the board now or in the future after so many years have past? After all, the same standard isn't applied to those seeking public office.
I'd like to see what happens if it is found that any current or past members of the Middletown Board of Education is affected by this new law. How will it be handle, will the public know about the real reason why a for current member's was removed or stepped down or why a past member seeking reappointment was past over or barred from running again?
Now don't jump to conclusions here on me, I am not making insinuations about anyone currently presiding on the BOE or who has stepped down recently. I am just pointing out the potential ramifications this new law will have on those that wish to serve on a local school boards, whether it is Middletown's or some other town.
Friday, June 4, 2010
Leaders Lead Gerry or They Get Out Of The Way; Now's The Time For A Budget Advisory Committee
Gerry Scharfenberger may be able to talk a good game in order to give the impression that he is always on top of the situation, but all he really ever does is blow and bluster a lot of hot air that makes people turn their heads and look the other way. Good examples of this was his recent handling of the school budget and how he has thus far refused to consider the idea of establishing a budget advisory committee that could help formulate and propose the fiscal budgets for not only Middletown but also the Board of Education. It would rely on shared services and greater cooperation between the two governing bodies and would save the Township tax payers hundreds of thousands of dollars now and in the future.
Democratic Committeeman Sean Byrnes has been proposing for the past 3 years that the Township set up some form of financial advisory committee that could sit down, look at, discuss and propose ideas to the Township Committee that could help shape and steer the budget processes in order to find potential fiscal issues or problems that would hamper the budget process that would prevent the Township from having a fiscal budget in place by January 1st each year as opposed to 5,6 or 8 months into the calender/fiscal year.
Each time Byrnes has presented his idea for some type finance committee he has been rebuffed by Gerry Scharfenberger and his fellow GOP members on the Township Committee with Scharfenberger's excuse always being the same, that he thinks it's every committee persons job to look at and take responsibility over budget issues, even though it is inefficient to do so.
Byrnes's latest proposal for a finance committee is a sound one and makes a lot of sense. It would be a joint budget revue and advisory committee that would include members of the Middletown Township Committee, members of the Middletown Board of Education and residents with budgeting expertise, for the purpose of making recommendations for sharing services, consolidating functions and for opportunities to consolidate maintenance and recreation functions. The goal of the committee would be reduce budget spending of each body by 2.5% in budget year 2011.
Committeeman Byrnes discussed his new proposal at the May 3rd workshop meeting where it received cool support from Gerry Scharfenberger and Committeewoman Pam Brightbill, who had earlier that met with members of the Board of Education to discuss the failed school budget. Gerry and Pam both stated that much of what Byrnes had proposed was discussed already earlier in the day when they met school board members, so it was not necessary.
Byrnes stated that he would introduce a resolution at the regular May 17th Committee meeting regardless so that the discussions could be ongoing and not brushed aside when it seemed that now was a perfect time to engage the Board of Education is serious talks concerning shared services.
Committeeman Byrnes stayed true to his word and moved that his resolution for a budget review and advisory committee be introduced and considered for adoption, unfortunately no other member of the committee would second the introduction so the motion failed and the resolution was dropped from further discussion.
Having a budget advisory committee is not a new or novel idea, many non-profits and Fortune 500 companies have them as well as other governing bodies, the Republican controlled Monmouth County Board of Chosen Freeholders being one of them. They introduced their financial committee earlier this year and are very happy. So why do the republicans in Middletown continue to fight such a common sense idea? I can only speculate that the reasons against a finance committee of any kind is because outsiders would have access to the Township ledgers and would be able to see where and to whom all of the money goes, which would lead to questions and lack of control over township business that the ruling GOP have enjoyed for more than 25 years.
Gerry, you can't wait for Trenton to bail Middletown out of the mess we are in. Leaders lead or they get out of the way, it's that simple.
Below is the resolution that Committeeman Sean Byrnes introduced to the Township Committee on May 17th and failed to receive support from other committee members:
RESOLUTION TO CREATE A BUDGET REVIEW ADVISORY COMMITTEE
WHEREAS, the Township Committee is mindful of the difficult economic climate facing residents of the Township of Middletown and the hardships associated with any increased tax burden facing citizens of the Township of Middletown; and
WHEREAS, the Township has recently hired a new Chief Financial; and
WHEREAS, the voters of Middletown, recently rejected the budget proposed by the Middletown Township Board of Education, despite the Board of Education having undertaken substantial cuts in line item spending; and
WHEREAS, the State of New Jersey, the Township of Middletown and the Board of Education face a financial crisis unprecedented in recent times, and
WHEREAS, the Township Committee anticipates that municipalities and school boards will continue to operate in an austere budget environment where citizens demand efficiency, small government and the elimination of unnecessary or discretionary services, and
WHEREAS, the Township Committee believes that closer cooperation with the Board of Education will be necessary to meet the financial challenges ahead, and
WHEREAS, the Township Committee believes that consolidation of certain functions performed by both the Board of Education and the Township Committee should be seriously considered and adopted where appropriate; and that the process of developing these recommendations should be open to the public; and
WHEREAS, the Township Committee believes that shared services within the public entities within Middletown and with neighboring municipalities and boards of education must take place and that the size of Middletown Township leaves it well-suited to lead these efforts; and
WHEREAS, the Township Committee seeks to pursue all opportunities to improve efficiency, eliminate unnecessary spending and reduce the burden on its taxpayers;
NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED by the Township Committee of the Township of Middletown that the Township does hereby authorize and call upon the Board of Education to jointly convene a Budget Review Advisory Committee consisting of 2 members of the Township Committee, three members of the Board of Education and 2 members of the community with strong financial experience, preferably in a Fortune 500 environment, to meet regularly over the next 6 months and thereafter make recommendations to the Township Committee and the Board of Education for sharing services and consolidating functions. This Budget Review Advisory Committee will look specifically for opportunities to consolidate maintenance and recreation functions. The Budget Review Advisory Committee shall have a specific goal of reducing the combined spending of the Township Committee and Board of Education by 2.5% for fiscal year 2011
Tuesday, May 25, 2010
It's your Town Newsletter Volumn 2, Issue 10 For 5/17/10; Resolution 10-151 Outlining Defeated School Board Budget Cuts Included
In this edition the township bill list for the month is includes which makes the newsletter rather long. Also included are ordinances and resolutions that were voted on during the May 17th 2010, Middletown Township Committee meeting. These are at the end of the newsletter and can be reached using the links provided. The links are underlined in blue. There are links in the resolutions to bring you back to where you were originally.
Perhaps the most controversial resolution of the year, Resolution 10-151, which instructs the Middletown Board of Education to cut an additional $2.1M from its previously defeated school budget is also included. You can read what members of the Township Committee had to say about this resolution when it was introduced and voted on, as well as comments from members of the public that expressed concerns over the size and necessity of the additional spending cuts imposed.
As always, if you would like to be placed on a mailing list to have the It's Your Town Newsletter sent to your inbox, send an email to itsourtown@yahoo.com and request it.
As always, if you would like to be placed on a mailing list to have the It's Your Town Newsletter sent to your inbox, send an email to itsourtown@yahoo.com and request it.
It is important for everyone to know how our local government is being run and most of all, how our tax dollars are being managed.
Correction - At the top of page 2 of It's Your Town Newsletter the statement attributed to Deputy Mayor/Committeeman Tony Fiore is not accurate, it should read as follows:
"Committee looked very hard and tried not to cut that which would impact the children."
not
"Committee looked very hard and tried not to cut that which did not impact the children."
It was pointed out to me that a double negative was used in the sentences which
altered the meaning of what was said at the meeting. Sorry if there was any confusion.
altered the meaning of what was said at the meeting. Sorry if there was any confusion.
Tuesday, May 18, 2010
The Arrogance Of Mayor Gerry Scharfenberger Hiding Behind A Website
The following was sent in by a reader who attended last night's Middeltown Township Committee meeting and wanted to get something off their chest. This person supported the school budget and did not think it necessary, fair or honest of the Township Committee to impose further cuts to the school budget after apparently agreeing to ~$ 1.6M proposed by the Board of Education without first informing the school board of it.
After completely ignoring the invitation of the school board to hold a joint meeting in public ensuring maximum transparency to the process. The Mayor insisted on closed door meetings to discuss the defeated budget. At the workshop meeting resident after resident pleaded with the committee to hold an open forum were residents to discuss their concerns because roughly $10,000,000 had already been cut from the school budget prior to its defeat.
But the mayor who steadfastly refuses to hear the residents speak on regular committee issues prior to the committee voting, has been hiding in plain sight for years from the public, just as the majority of the committee has, unlike Democratic Committeeman Sean Byrnes, who has strived to make the committee operations more transparent and open to the public.
Finally after realizing the public could not be ignored the township set up a link so that residents could email concerns. It was a feeble attempt designed to once again hide in plain sight by receiving emails but refusing to hear in public or discuss residents concerns. While both the mayor and the deputy mayor championed the idea it demonstrated that they were only willing to receive the equivalent of a “Dear John” letter without facing the issue with the voters.
Not surprisingly they also stuck to the same pattern of hiding from the public by failing to place the resolution on the website, as was done with every other resolution of the evening. You have to wonder what the committee was trying to hide. It was not until after the vote and after the public was finally allowed to make statements that they finally disclosed the amount cut to a roomful of anxious school budget supporters.
They cut $2,090, 894 dollars from the school budget.
Ignoring all the information supplied by the superintendent and the school officials that they would be unable to cover state mandated requirements and insure student safety they cut more assistant principals from the already understaffed high schools.
But to add insult to injury they did not even have the courtesy to send a letter to the superintendent or the board president notifying them of the amount of the cut. It was just another example of the arrogance of the Mayor Gerry Scharfenberger not even to have the decency to notify school officials or the public about the cut.
Hiding behind a website is not transparency Gerry, its cowardice.
"The liberties of a people never were, nor ever will be, secure, when the transactions of their rulers may be concealed from them."
- Patrick Henry, American colonial revolutionary
"Government ought to be all outside and no inside. . . . Everybody knows that corruption thrives in secret places, and avoids public places, and we believe it a fair presumption that secrecy means impropriety."
- Woodrow Wilson
“Everybody knows that corruption thrives in secret places, and avoids public places, and we believe it is a fair presumption that secrecy means impropriety”
- Pres. Woodrow Wilson
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



